What is it about Israel that makes it so attractive to anti-Semites, fascists and racists such as Trump, Bolsonaro and Duterte?
Israel is proof that any group of people, including Jews, can, given
the right set of circumstances become racists and fascists.
Racism is not biologically inherited. It is a product of society not
genetics. Just as Germans today have not inherited a Hitler gene, so the same
is true of Israeli Jews. They have no inherited the mantle of the oppressed Jews of Europe but what Israel
has done is to transform the traditional image of Jews from the oppressed to the
oppressor.
 |
| Professor Ze'ev Sternhell, a child survivor of a Nazi Ghetto sees in Israel the signs of pre-Holocaust Germany |
According to Sternhell fascists and anti-Semites,
amongst whom I include Trump, don’t see Israel as Jewish. The Zionist dream
was always to create a nation like all other nations. They succeeded only too well. The settler nation that they created is the most right-wing and racist of any nation on Earth.
 |
| Woody Allen - the archetypal Jew of the diaspora |
Israel is the only state, bar
Liberia, where Donald Trump is more popular than unpopular. Whereas Jews were
historically seen as weak, intellectuals, cosmopolitan, erudite, artists,
seditious and on the Left, Israel is seen as a warrior state, a military
fortress. The archetypal Jew was a Woody Allen, Franz Kafka, Einstein and Marc
Chagall. To Hitler the archetypal Jew was
Karl Marx. The archetypal Israeli Jew is a racist bigot who revels in murder.
 |
| Geert Wilders, the Dutch Fascist leader speaking in Tel Aviv in 2010. Unlike Rashid Tlaib and Ilhan Omar he was not banned from Israel |
Israel according
to Dutch fascist leader Geert Wilders is the front-line in the battle to defend
Western civilisation. It is admired by every fascist or far-Right leader on the
planet – from Brazil’s Bolsonaro to the Philipine’s Hitler loving President
Duterte.
In Britain it is the English Defence
League and Tommy Robinson’s Football Lads Alliance who parade with Israeli flags.
Tommy Robinson and Katie Hopkins both admire Israel and the way it
combats ‘Islam’. Katie Hopkins
understands this when she justifies the bomb attack against refugee supporting Jews
at Pittsburgh whilst at the same time proclaiming her undying devotion to the Israeli
state.
 |
| Netanyahu with his friend, Viktor Orban, the anti-Semitic ruler of Hungary |
Don’t blame
Trump, Hopkins wrote
in respect of the Pittsburgh shooting. Rather, “Look to the Chief Rabbi and his
support for mass migration across the Med[iterranean],” she wrote. “There you
will find your truths.”
As Finkelstein says Israel isn’t
merely an alt-Right state but an alt-Right country. It isn’t simply a question
of a far-Right government but a far-Right citizenry. ‘Israel has no left. Israel has
no centre’. It has a Right,
far-Right and further Right still.
Israel’s
attractions to the alt-Right is that it is an ethno-nationalist state. Which is
why the neo-Nazi founder of the alt-Right Richard Spencer described himself as
a White Zionist and supported
Israel’s Jewish Nation State Law.
Israel represents
the kind of state, an ethno-nationalist state, that Spencer, Trump and Bannon are trying to
build in the United States. Israel provides the model. It is trying to deport thousands of refugees
because they aren’t from the majority ethnic group in Israel and therefore threaten
Israel’s Jewish identity.
Finkelstein described Israel as a nation of murderers and
he’s not far wrong. When you have a
demonstration in Tel Aviv in the middle of the attack on Gaza in 2014 which
chanted ‘there’s no school in Gaza
tomorrow, there are no children left’ i.e. boasting about the number of
children murdered by Israel, then you realise that this is not a normal nation
but a settler colonial state with all that entails. See Far-right
Israelis celebrate Gaza kids’ deaths
 |
| Efraim Zuroff |
The article below is by a Zionist,
Efraim Zuroff, from the Simon Wiesenthall Centre. Even he finds it difficult to stomach the
open alliance between Israel and the far-Right and anti-Semitic regimes in Europe
today.
Bibi, when you visit countries
that no longer have Jews, maybe don't praise the first line they give you about
how much they've fought anti-Semitism since the war
Times of Israel Aug 27, 2019,
Prime Minister Netanyahu’s trip to Ukraine early last week is yet
another opportunity to assess Israel’s relations with the post-Communist new
democracies of Eastern Europe, and especially those with a Holocaust past of
participation in the systematic mass murder of Jews. In this respect, Ukraine
in recent years has been one of the worst offenders in terms of distorting the
history of the Holocaust, and glorifying individuals who collaborated with the
Nazis in implementing the Final Solution.
 |
Thousands of Ukrainian nationalists hold a torchlight procession across Kiev in honor of Stepan Bandera, a World War II anti-Soviet insurgent, on January 1, 2015 (photo credit: AFP/Genya Savilov)
|
The deterioration of the situation is directly linked to local politics
and the conflict with Russia over the annexation of Crimea in 2014 and the
ongoing insurgency in Eastern Ukraine. Thus, for example, in May 2015, the
Ukrainian Parliament passed a package of laws, one of which outlaws criticism
of those who fought for Ukrainian statehood in the 20th century, despite the
fact that it is indisputable that militias established in 1941 by the
Organization of Ukrainian Nationalists (OUN), one of the most important movements
that sought to achieve statehood, were active participants in the wave of
anti-Jewish violence which swept Western Ukraine during the weeks following the
Nazi invasion of the Soviet Union in June 1941. In fact, according to Swedish
Holocaust historian Per Rudling, the most recent research on the involvement of
the OUN in these actions, indicates that they participated in the murder of at
least “thousands, perhaps even as many as tens of thousands, of Jews.”
 |
| Netanhahu at Yad Vashem - Israel's Holocaust Propaganda Museum |
This is only one small, but highly indicative, detail of the numerous
steps taken by Ukrainian institutions and historians to whitewash the
large-scale participation of their nationals in Holocaust crimes. The country
is full of memorials and statues to Ukrainian Nazi collaborators and torchlight
parades to honor the leaders of the OUN and UPA (Ukrainian Insurgent Army,
which developed out of the OUN) are a common occurrence. Streets are named for
OUN leader Stefan Bandera, whose birthday was recently declared a national
holiday. In addition, quite a few Holocaust memorials have been defaced or
vandalized in recent years, and not a single perpetrator of such crimes, or any
other anti-Semitic acts, has ever been prosecuted, let alone convicted and
punished, since Ukraine achieved independence with the fall of the Soviet
Union.
The question is how should Israel respond, if at all, to these steps and
to what extent should the rampant Holocaust distortion affect Israeli-Ukrainian
relations? Unlike the situation in other post-Communist new democracies, where,
for the most part, our ambassadors have refrained from getting involved in
historical issues, our new ambassador in Kyiv, Joel Lion, has criticized
initiatives to honor Holocaust perpetrators on at least three occasions, and
has done so in at least one case with the Polish ambassador, since the “hero”
in question was also involved in murdering Poles.
 |
| Netanyahu pays tribute to the Ukrainian regime which is rehabilitating Stefan Bandera and other Nazi collaborators |
In retrospect, we are now in a position to assess current Israeli policy
regarding Holocaust distortion, following Prime Minister Netanyahu’s state
visit to Kyiv. Sad to say, but it strongly reminded me of his trip this past
September to Lithuania, another prime offender when it comes to
Holocaust-related issues. In fact, for many years, Lithuania was the country
most active in initiating the cardinal tenets of Holocaust distortion, i.e.,
minimizing or hiding the participation of locals in Nazi crimes, promoting the
canard of equivalency between Nazi and Communist crimes, glorifying anti-Soviet
heroes despite their role in the Shoah, and lobbying for a joint memorial day
for all the victims of totalitarian regimes, which would make International
Holocaust Remembrance Day superfluous. Instead of drawing attention to these
problematic policies, Netanyahu praised his hosts for the manner in which they
sought to commemorate the Shoah, and, for good measure, he also lauded their
(relatively nonexistent or at best minimal) efforts to fight anti-Semitism.
 |
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, left, and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky, right, stand at Babi Yar ravine where Nazi troops murdered tens of thousands of Jews during WWII, in Kyiv, Ukraine, August 19, 2019. (AP Photo/Zoya Shu)
|
This modus operandi was exactly replicated in Kyiv, which in recent
years has by far surpassed Vilnius in its blatant Holocaust distortion and
brazen systematic attempts to totally falsify the historical narrative of World
War II and the Holocaust. Thus, for example, at Babi Yar, the site of the
biggest Holocaust massacre, Netanyahu thanked the Ukrainian government for its
efforts to preserve the memory of the Holocaust, and mentioned their
(nonexistent) “efforts in the war against anti-Semitism.” The grotesque irony
of these comments was noted by Israeli journalist Sam Sokol writing in The
Times of Israel. In his analysis of the visit, he pointed out that Babi Yar can
serve as an excellent illustration of Ukrainian Holocaust distortion, as the
Ukrainians seek to commemorate OUN members there alongside Shoah victims.
If anyone is looking for a silver lining in this sad story, at least
Netanyahu did not agree to recognize the Holodomor as a genocide (which it
wasn’t) and he mentioned “Nazi collaborators,” several times, although the
Ukrainians, like the Lithuanians, might attempt to claim that the term also
includes members of the Judenrat and/or the Jewish police in local ghettos.
In short, Israeli policy on Holocaust-related issues in post-Communist
Eastern Europe remains flawed and shameful, but it remains to be seen, exactly
how it can be improved, a subject which I hope to address in a coming op-ed.
About the Author
Dr. Efraim Zuroff is the chief Nazi-hunter of the Simon Wiesenthal
Center and the director of the Center's Israel Office and Eastern European
Affairs.
See also
No comments:
Post a Comment
Please submit your comments below