21 November 2026

An Open Letter to Susan Abulhawa on Why Your Conflict is not with Western Jewry but with the Imperialist War Machine That Feeds the Genocide

You are Simply Wrong to Say That the Genocide in Gaza ‘is wholly Jewish in its implementation’.

Susan Abulhawa | This House Believes Israel is an Apartheid State Responsible for Genocide

Susan Abulhawa is a Palestinian-American writer, novelist, poet  and activist, best known for her bestselling novel Mornings in Jenin and for founding the children's organization Playgrounds for Palestine.

On November 29, 2024, Abulhawa was invited by the Oxford Union to debate the motion "This House Believes Israel is an Apartheid State Responsible for Genocide". She spoke in favour of the motion which was carried with a majority of 278 to 59. The Oxford Union later deleted her original recording on YouTube and uploaded a censored version. The parts of Abulhawa's speech that were edited out by the Oxford Union included her mentions of the IDF's abuse of Palestinian and Lebanese civilians and the IDF's use of "booby trapped toys"

Abulhawa recently posted an article on her substack expressing her outrage at the continued genocide in Gaza and Jewish support for the genocide.  It is an outrage we all feel.

The International Court of Justice has found just found Myanmar guilty of perpetrating a genocide against the Rohinga. It was an application that Britain supported when it intervened in the case brought by Gambia. Over 10,000 people were massacred. The same British government, first under the ‘Zionist without qualification’ Keir Starmer and now Andy Burnham, says that it cannot express an opinion on whether Israel is guilty of genocide when over 75,000 Palestinians (at the very minimum) have been murdered.

I decided to write an open letter to Susan Abulhawa because, although understandable, her statement that ‘material Zionism (i.e. the Genocide) ... is wholly Jewish in its implementation’ . is, I believe profoundly mistaken.

Tony Greenstein

Dear Susan,

I want to say a few things before I explain why your article on substack is wrong, dangerously wrong.

Firstly I have the greatest admiration for your passion and integrity, which we witnessed two years ago in the debate at Oxford Union. Your speech was a magnificent tour de force with passion and articulacy going hand in hand.

Secondly I admire your refusal to let the racist censors and hypocrites of the Oxford Union, who are happy to invite fascists like Tommy Robinson to speak in the name of ‘freedom of speech’ triumph. The Oxford Union was willing to excise from the record those parts of your speech which the Zionists and supporters of genocide objected to. The Oxford Union retreated and agreed a settlement on your terms.

Thirdly I understand the pain that you and Palestinians feel about the fact that many Jews in the West have either supported the genocide or remained silent whilst their ‘leaders’ supported the starvation, the rapes, the mass murder and all the other atrocities.

I share in your pain, not least because Jews above all should be the first to condemn Israel’s genocide given their own experiences. However Zionism, the political and ideological heir to Hitler and the Nazis, has no such qualms.

Not only am I pained but I’m also angry that those who claim to represent the memory of the Jews who died at the hands of the Nazis, use that memory in order to justify Israel’s genocide and extermination. In so doing they defile the memory of those they claim to respect.


​"A VICTORY FOR FREE SPEECH": Tony Greenstein speaks following his acquittal at Kingston Crown Court

As I said in my speech to Kingston Crown Court last August,

What I have always fought against was those who used the murder of 6 million Jews in order to justify the murder and genocide of others.

However I can’t agree with your comments about the debate about Zionism being irrelevant or your belief that the genocide ‘is wholly Jewish in its implementation’. This is simply not true. What you are doing is letting off the hook those who are responsible for funding and arming Israel.

The United States does not supply billions of dollars of arms to Israel and Andy Burnham does not allow RAF flights overflying Gaza to collect intelligence for the IDF because they love Jews so much. Friedrich Merz doesn’t supply 30% of the weapons used in the genocide because he is wracked by guilt over Germany’s role in the holocaust of Jews.

Imperialism supports the Israeli state because it sees it as in its interests to have a stable settler-colonial state at the heart of a vital region, economically and strategically. It was Napoleon who first supported the idea of a ‘Jewish’ state in Palestine. This was taken up by a raft of British imperialists from Lord Palmerston to Arthur Balfour and Winston Churchill. They all saw the advantages of an armed settler state setting Arab against Arab and bolstering authoritarian Arab states.

I share your anger at the role of all too many Jews in supporting the genocide in the name of fighting ‘anti-Semitism’. I detest war criminals like Chief Rabbi Mirvis who has played the role of genocide cheer leader. Mirvis’s place is in Nuremberg not the House of Lords. He is no different from Father Tiso, the priest and President of the Nazi puppet state Slovakia who was hanged as a collaborator.

Those Jews who cheerlead the genocide whilst denying it is happening are no better than neo-Nazi holocaust deniers. It is no wonder that their best friends are people like Tommy Robinson and Nigel Farage. Zionism today has shed its social democratic pretensions. It is an openly far-right pastime.

But I would also caution against the assumption that most Jews outside Israel are supporters of the genocide. The United States is a very good example. All the major Jewish organisations are Zionist organisations and fully committed to an Israel right or wrong stance.


But as yourself admitted half of the Jewish population in Michigan voted for Abdul el-Sayed for Sentor. In fact it was between 57% and 60%.

Even in Britain, which has a more conservative Jewish population 24% describe themselves as anti-Zionist or non-Zionist. But among young Jews (20-29) 24% identify as anti-Zionist and 20% as non-Zionist.

In the United States just 37% of Jews identify as Zionists compared to 66% in Britain. 32% of young Jews (18-34) identify as anti-Zionist or non-Zionist.

39% of American Jews say Israel is committing genocide compared to 51% who don’t. But regardless it is irrelevant how many Jews support or oppose the genocide. It is not Jews, either in this country or the United States who are responsible for western support for Israel but the elites in both countries. Jews are the moral alibi for western imperialism.


As Al  Haig was reputed to have said, ‘Israel is the largest American aircraft carrier in the world that cannot be sunk, ... and is located in a critical region for American national security.’ Or as Joe Biden said, if Israel did not exist it would have had to be invented.

Expelled Ugandan Asians Arrive at Schipol, Amsterdam

Jews occupy the same position in relation to US imperialism that groups like South Asians and Indians occupied in the British colonies in East Africa. These middlemen minorities often took the brunt of anger of the Africans, resulting in the Ugandan Asians being expelled altogether in August 1972.

You say that ‘The raging debate on the origin of zionism is academic’ during a genocide and that ‘I don't care if zionism was first a Christian idea.’ Well you should. This debate is crucial to winning the argument that there is nothing Jewish about Zionism. That is why Molly Crabapple and Ben Moser’s books are so important.

We have to change the terms of debate. Zionism and the imperialists use Jews, ‘anti-Semitism’ and Jewish ‘safety’ as a justification for the genocide, a moral comfort blanket.

We have to make it clear that Zionism, far from being a Jewish phenomenon was the product of Christian anti-Semitism. That Christian Zionism rested on the belief that Jews did not belong in non-Jewish society. Which is why, during the Nazi era, the Zionists were only too willing to work with the Nazis.  These are not irrelevant questions.

So when you say that the genocide and ethnic cleansing (‘material Zionism) ‘is wholly Jewish in its implementation’ you could not be more wrong. Without American and German                                    weapons, British overflights of Gaza supplying intelligence and economic and political support Israel could not have carried out the genocide. Starmer, Biden, Merz and Trump are every bit as much war criminals as Netanyahu and Gallant.

You talk of how all the

"holocaust museums"... have either been silent on this first live-streamed genocide in human history, or they've closed ranks with other mainstream Jewish institutions, all of them running cover and giving support to Israel,

This is very true. It was why I wrote Zionism During the Holocaust whose subtitle is the ‘weaponisation of memory in the service of State and Nation.’ The Holocaust has been used as a propaganda weapon to cloak western imperialism and its Israeli guard dog in the mantle of the holocaust dead.

Why do you think that the US Holocaust Museum exists in Washington, lavishly funded by the American tax payer, yet there is no equivalent museum to slavery or the extermination of the Native Americans? The numbers of slaves and indigenous Americans who were slaughtered is far greater than 6 million yet there is no inclination to remember them because there are no strategic or political imperatives to do so.

The behaviour of all these institutions is shameful. For Zionists ‘never again’ means never again for Jews not for everyone. When the Los Angeles Holocaust Museum posted a graphic on Instagram with the message ‘Never again can’t only mean never again for Jews’, there was an immediate backlash from the Zionists. Their complaint was that the statement might be interpreted as referring to Israel’s genocide in Gaza, resulted in the post being deleted. The museum issued a new statement:

We recently posted an item on social media that was part of a pre-planned campaign intended to promote inclusivity and community that was easily open to misinterpretation by some to be a political statement reflecting the ongoing situation in the Middle East. That was not our intent.

Karen Pollock of the Holocaust Education Trust went even further. She condemned the ‘shameful’ comparisons between the holocaust in Gaza and the Nazi genocide.

We should take on board what Primo Levi and his interviewer concluded in an interview in 1982 after the massacre of Palestinians in the Sabra and Chatilla refugee camps.

Joan Acocella recalled how Primo Levi, the famous Italian Jewish survivor of Auschwitz, told a reporter, Filippo Gentiloni, from the Italian newspaper Il Manifesto, that

“Everybody is somebody’s Jew,”.... At that point in the interview, printed on June 29, 1982, Gentiloni closed the Levi quote and added a sentence of his own: “And today Palestinians are the Jews of the Israelis.” 

You say that you want to talk about the dangers that Jewish supremacy poses to humanity, and to Palestinians in particular. This is dangerous talk. Not because it endangers Jews because it endangers Palestinians by poisoning and polluting their narrative.

If what you mean is the Jewish Supremacism that we see in Israel then that is simply a description of the racism that always accompanies settler colonialism. White Supremacism was a feature of South Africa Apartheid and the Jim Crow Deep South. Colonialism and in particular its settler colonial variant is always, without exception, racially supremacist. Jewish Supremacism is a function of Zionism, which you think we should not talk about.

But if what you mean Jewish Supremacism outside Israel then you are in danger of playing into the hands of the far-right conspiracy theorists. It is absurd to talk of Jewish Supremacy in the United States where Jews form less than 2.5% of the population. In Britain Jews form about 0.5%. Jews are singled out by our rulers for ‘protection’ against anti-Semitism precisely because the mainly non-Jewish ruling class wants to associate Jews with British support for the Israeli state.  Imperialism always wants a moral rationale for its actions.


Bruce Springsteen - Streets Of Minneapolis (Official Audio)

But I also want to take this opportunity to raise the real political problem of this genocide. It is a question that is rarely discussed. It is the family secret that is kept under lock and key. You say that

Besides the apathy of the Arab masses and complicity of Arab governments, nothing in this genocide has surprised me more than the widespread support Israel continues to enjoy among western Jews

I have already made clear my own disgust at the support of western Jews for the genocide. After all it was nine of these misfits who reported me to the police for my alleged support for Hamas. But even if the majority of western Jews had opposed the genocide from day one then that would have made no difference to the West’s support for the genocide.

But if the Arab masses had risen up against their own rulers, their collaboration and complicity with Israel, then I have no doubt that Israel would have been halted in its tracks.

We have seen how the Houthis and Iran, because of the wars forced upon them, have forced the United States to pull in its horns.  It is the failure of the Arab revolution that allows Israel to get away with its genocide.

The interdiction by Ansarallah (Houthis) of Israeli ships and its closing of Eilat, was the only contribution that the Arab world has made to the fight against Israel. Today the ruler of Syria, Abu Mohammad al-Jolani, of Al Qaeda’s franchise in Syria, HTS, is in league with Israel and the United States.

The Palestinian leadership and the PLO bear a great deal of responsibility for having agreed to the Oslo Accords which disarmed the Palestinians and turned them into their own policemen. The Palestinian Authority has become Israel’s military sub-contractor.

The PLO, even before Oslo, had no ambition other than to become another repressive Arab regime. Whereas most liberation movements, at least until they achieve power, have a radical social programme which could appeal to others outside their ranks, the major Palestinian organisations had nothing to say about capitalism and imperialism, still less about the corrupt and repressive Arab regimes.

The PLO preferred Saudi and Gulf funding of their diplomatic offices throughout the world to support for revolutionary struggle in those countries. I except groups like the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine. The mere fact that Hamas, the Islamic Resistance Movement, could rise to power in Gaza speaks volumes about the political bankruptcy of the main Palestinian resistance force, Fateh.

It is this, not Jewish Supremacy, which has been the major obstacle to Palestinian liberation. In making their bed with the Arab regimes, the PLO took the road to Oslo and eventually the Abraham Accords.

If you single out Jewish Supremacy and exempt western imperialism you mistake the symptoms for the disease.

Tony Greenstein

10 November 2026

The Case of Dr. Kirpichonok: How Israel’s Secret Police Set Out to Destroy an Anti-Zionist Historian

What Kind of State Kidnaps Someone, Tortures  Them Into Confessing, Gags the Press and then Imprisons His Lawyer? Step Forward Israel 
Artyom Kirpichonok in Happier Times in St Petersburg

At 10:50 am on August 2, 2026, Russian-Israeli historian and Orientalist Artyom Kirpichonok arrived at Ben-Gurion airport. Kirpichonok had flown from Yerevan, the capital of Armenia. Just minutes before, at 10:41 am, he managed to send a brief message to his relatives: “Landed.” Dr Kirpichonok, a dual Israeli-Russian citizen was not to know that he would never make it out of the airport.

Is Israel Cracking Down? The Arrest of Kirpichonok | Alexander Kolpakidi and Mikhail Magid

Israel’s secret police, the Shabak were lying in wait. Within moments, his phone was forcibly disconnected, and all communication ceased. According to law enforcement data, he successfully cleared border control at 2:00 PM, but the scientist never reached the rented apartment in Ashkelon left behind after his parents passed away.

To all intents and purpose Kirpichonok had been disappeared. Despite its façade as a democratic state, Israel has past form when it comes to disappearing people for long stretches as a time.

After disappearing from public contact on August 2, 2026, Dr. Artyom Kirpichenok (Kirpichonok), a 51-year-old prominent anti-Zionist critic, was held incommunicado under a strict judicial gag order. On September 4, 2026, he was formally indicted on security charges, including espionage and contacting an agent of a foreign intelligence service. Prosecutors allege that he undertook clandestine influence operations against Israel under instructions from foreign intelligence, specifically pointing to multiple trips he made to Iran. His legal defense and family contend that his arrest is a case of political persecution, noting that he had no access to classified state secrets.

Israel has a long-documented history of employing media blackouts, court-enforced gag orders, and anonymous detention—often referred to as the "Prisoner X" system—to secretly incarcerate citizens or intelligence assets suspected of treason or espionage.

Dr Kirpichenok is not the only Israeli to have been disappeared but unlike the others he is clearly innocent of the charges. The only motive for his arrest and disappearance is political. Others include:

A general view of the Ayalon Prison in the city of Ramla, central Israel, Jan. 8, 2026. Photo by Yossi Aloni/Flash90.

Ben Zygier: A dual Australian-Israeli national who worked for Mossad, Israel’s MI6. In early 2010, Zygier was secretly arrested and held in absolute isolation under a false identity in Ayalon Prison. Even his prison guards were entirely unaware of his true identity. The government enforced a total media blackout regarding his existence. He died by suicide in December 2010 while still in solitary confinement. His imprisonment and identity remained completely hidden from the public until an Australian broadcaster exposed the story in early 2013.

Rumours of the potential existence of a prisoner who was held in Israel for unspecified crimes at Ayalon Prison, a maximum-security prison in Ramla, first surfaced when an Israeli news website (Ynet) briefly posted an article about him in 2010. The article was taken down within hours, and was allegedly removed because the Israeli security services had a gag order imposed. These reports claimed that the man was confined in total seclusion and was being housed in the cell that was built for Yigal Amir, the assassin of Yitzhak Rabin. 

"Prisoner X2": Following the exposure of Ben Zygier's death, Israeli officials acknowledged the existence of a second anonymous detainee. "Prisoner X2" was a senior Mossad operative who was secretly jailed in Ayalon Prison around 2004 under total secrecy. He was convicted of severe treason and espionage on behalf of Iran. His existence was kept a state secret for nearly a decade until it leaked in July 2013. Reports indicate he was quietly released from custody in May 2018

Marcus Klingberg

Marcus Klingberg: A Polish-born Israeli epidemiologist and deputy director of the top-secret Israel Institute for Biological Research. In 1983, Klingberg ‘disappeared’ entirely from public view after being arrested by the Shin Bet for spying for the Soviet Union. For a decade, the Israeli government enforced a blanket gag order on the case. His family was compelled to tell acquaintances he was receiving medical treatment in Europe. His secret 20-year prison sentence was not publicly disclosed until a legal leak occurred in 1993.

The Association for Civil Rights in Israel sent a letter to the Attorney General, Yehuda Weinstein, protesting the conditions of this man's detention. The chief legal counsel for the Association, Dan Yakir, wrote:

It is insupportable that, in a democratic country, authorities can arrest people in complete secrecy and disappear them from public view without the public even knowing such an arrest took place.

Kirpichenok's book - Why Did the Counter-Revolution Win in Russia? The Right Wing Against the Truth,

 Weinstein's deputy replied that

The current gag order is vital for preventing a serious breach of the state's security, so we can not elaborate about this affair


Russian writer Artem Kirpichenok arrested in Israel

For his colleagues, this disappearance came as a stunning shock. By concealing his arrest under the shroud of a judicial gag order, the Zionist regime counted on complete silence.

Kirpichenok book St. Petersburg. Walks with a Breeze. A Guidebook for Scooters and Bicycles

Kirpichenok was born and brought up in St Petersburg. He was taken by his mother to Israel in 1991, when the USSR collapsed. He wrote articles for Russian and Turkish media and was active in anti-Zionist meetings.

It appears that he was enticed to come to Israel by the Shabak; though he frequently visited Israel, where he had a flat and many friends. In Israel, they have no habeas corpus. The secret service can keep its prisoners for years without trial and even without specific charges. There are thousands of prisoners without charges, most Palestinian, but Jews too can be imprisoned without trial or charges.

Kirpichenok’s last published column in TRT was We are proud of being hated, the previous one being The Arab citizens of Israel from Ghetto to Apartheid. His most popular book is The People’s History of Israel.

One of Artem Kirpichenok eight books - Notes of a Man from Atlantis,


Kirpichonok is a recognized researcher of Zionism and the history of the Middle East. He graduated from the Hebrew University of Jerusalem, defended his doctoral dissertation under the supervision of Professor Jonathan Frankel, and in recent years lived in St. Petersburg, Russia, heading the Slavic Studies Department at the Center for Arab-Eurasian Studies. He worked as a tour guide and wrote analytical columns for major publications. His books became the primary target of Zionist hatred.

A People's History of Israel 

In "A People's History of Israel", Kirpichenok argued that the victims of Zionism are not only Palestinians but also the Jewish communities of repatriants themselves. This book, named by analogy with the works of Howard Zinn, became his most popular and accurate study, exposing a profound internal rift within Israeli society.

Statement by Sergey Baburin

In a special statement by the International Association of Peace Foundations, Sergey Baburin, former Deputy Chairman of the State Duma of the Russian Federation, emphasized the strictly scientific and historically accurate nature of Kirpichonok's anti-Zionist stance.

Daria Barabanova's Appeal to Russia's Ambassador to Israel - the Translation is here

Concurrently, Daria Barabanova, an actress, choreographer, ballet master, and director from St. Petersburg, pointed out the complete vulnerability of the lonely researcher in an appeal to the Russian Ambassador to Israel.

Past trips made by Kirpichenok to Iran served as an additional pretext for persecution. In a talk on the lecture platform "Book Center × Delib", analyst Mikhail Magid confirmed that friends repeatedly tried to dissuade him from the fateful trip, understanding the vengefulness of the Israeli authorities. However, Shin Bet lured the financially struggling scientist into a trap by sending a fake invitation to a fictional conference with the promise of a grant.

Daria Mitina, a former deputy of the State Duma of the Russian Federation, was the first to announce Kirpichonok's arrest and his incarceration in the dungeons of Shin Bet, breaking the information blockade in the early days of August.

In a special report by the Latin American television network teleSUR, journalist Oleg Yasinsky brought the affair to an international level, calling Kirpichonok a defender of the rights of the Palestinian people and emphasizing his significant contribution to the education of Jewish communities. Following them, in CounterPunch magazine, artist, writer, and founder of the David Graeber Institute Nika Dubrovsky published an essay titled "They Are Coming for the Penguins", referencing a famous poem by the early 20th-century Russian Soviet writer Maxim Gorky.

Dubrovsky explained that Kirpichonok is a peaceful, defenseless "penguin" hiding his body in the cliffs, who did not belong to any radical organisations. His arrest is a demonstrative example aimed at eliminating any safe "zones of anomaly" and forcing the intelligentsia into silence. In a world where the water in public discourse is rapidly boiling, Shin Bet demonstrates that from now on, the space of the personal and the prison cell merge into a single reality.

As Magid noted in an interview with the socio-political channel "Krasnye Dyadki", Netanyahu's regime carried out a purge of the security services on the eve of the elections, appointing radicals who required an "internal enemy." In another piece in CounterPunch, Vijay Prashad, Director of the Tricontinental: Institute for Social Research, supplemented the picture with frightening statistics of repression: Shin Bet arrested more than 1,400 citizens for anti-war publications on social media.

Although there are still a few fools who believe that Israel is a parliamentary democracy and the embodiment of what it means to be Jewish, what happened next was confirmation that Israel belongs to that group of states where the security services can act with impunity.

Inna Lebedinskaya-Katz 

Israeli lawyer Inna Lebedinskaya-Katz remained Kirpichonok's sole defender. She was denied access to her client for 20 days while he was being broken in the Petah Tikva detention center. At their first meeting, a Kafkaesque underbelly of the investigation came to light, which Yaakov Rabkin, a professor at the University of Jerusalem, characterised in an interview with the Swiss channel Neutrality Studies as an absolute absurdity: his lawyer was forbidden to bring with her even a blank sheet of paper and was forced to memorise all statements by ear through bulletproof glass.

Artem Kirpichenok

It is known from investigative materials in Anhar Kochneva's military blog on Yandex.Zen that Kirpichonok was subjected to sleep deprivation torture, being interrogated continuously for 18–24 hours a day. The historian, whose vision is minus 11 dioptres, was kept in shackles on an iron chair under the blinding light of lamps for days on end. In an interview with the socio-political portal "Rabkor", Magid emphasised that under conditions of brain function deterioration from multi-day sleep deprivation, Kirpichonok was forced to sign self-incrimination protocols.

Only international pressure from the Russian Presidential Council for Human Rights, which sent an appeal to the UN, forced the censorship to back down. Citing this move, Israeli journalist Itamar Eichner published an investigation in Ynet that tore away the veil of secrecy. Richard Silverstein pointed out in his blog Tikun Olam that Shin Bet is using the historian as a geopolitical hostage in the confrontation surrounding Iran.

On September 4, the State Attorney's Office filed charges of "espionage for Russia" against Kirpichonok in Lod District Court. On October 1 Inna Lebedinskaya-Katz gave a detailed video interview to the RT Arabic television channel. She openly called the prosecution's accusations "Scheherazade's tales"—a fantastic fiction completely devoid of real documents and built on self-incrimination extracted under torture. As Daria Mitina and Anhar Kochneva noted earlier, investigators applied unacceptable methods of pressure to her client, depriving him of sleep and threatening him with a life sentence.

Inna Leybedinskaya-Katz was also arrested - Israel's justice system is quite unique for a self-declared democracy

The retaliation of the Iscoraeli state followed immediately: Shin Bet arrested the lawyer for defending her client. Lebedinskaya-Katz was thrown in gaol, depriving Kirpichonok of legal assistance. To arrest the lawyer demonstrated, as if it needs demonstrating, that Israel’s judicial processes are a charade. When they choose, the State and its secret police simply do what they want with the judiciary giving a rubber stamp of approval.

Kirpichonok is currently being held in a maximum-security block at Ayalon Prison. According to updates by Mikhail Magid, the researcher has completely lost sight in one eye due to the lack of medical care under conditions of torture. B’Tselem, Israel’s human rights organization, describes Israeli prisons as a network of torture camps.

Letter from the State Comptroller and Ombudsman of Israel rejecting ACRI's complaint (Case No. 1254441), declaring a lack of jurisdiction over judicial matters.

The Office of the State Comptroller and Ombudsman, in response to a complaint from relatives under number № 1254441, stated its refusal to interfere in the affairs of the judicial system.

The Association for Civil Rights in Israel (ACRI) cited procedural limitations in its response. The sole international legal shield has been the decision by the Scholars at Risk network to include Artyom's case in its global Academic Freedom Monitoring Project.

At the same time, the Office of the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights registered a complaint filed by human rights defenders regarding the arrest of Kirpichonok and his lawyer under tracking number 1bblaq2e.

The world's leading thinkers have joined the solidarity campaign. A joint open letter in defense of Kirpichonok has been signed by philosopher Judith Butler (USA), physicist and co-author of Noam Chomsky Jean Bricmont (Belgium), Fellow of the Royal Society of Canada Professor Darko Suvin, Member of the Order of the British Empire Professor Tariq Modood, and Professor of Psychological Sciences Felicia Pratto.

The only force against the secret police is stubborn human memory. Kirpichonok and Inna's personal Facebook profiles preserve the evidence of their public academic and legal work, while the website for the campaign to defend Artyom Kirpichonok and the coordination email address ArtemKirpichenok@gmail.com remain available for anyone ready to visit and add their name to the Open Letter in Defense of the Historian.

The scientist and his lawyer must not vanish into the darkness of Israeli detention facilities.

You are Not Allowed to Criticise Israel. The Case of Artyom Kirpichenok

They are Coming for the Penguins: Artem Ivanovich Kirpichenok is in a Shin Bet Prison in Israel

BREAKING: Shin Bet Disappears Russian-Israeli Academic

Tony Greenstein 

Dear Colleagues!

I am writing to you in connection with the critical situation that has developed around the arrest in Israel by the SHABAK special service of the scholar-historian Dr. Artyom Kirpichyonok and his lawyer Inna Lebedinskaya-Katz.

On August 2, 2026, Dr. Kirpichyonok arrived in Israel to participate in academic events and on personal matters. After passing border control at the Ben Gurion International Airport, he was detained by the Israel Security Agency SHABAK (Shin Bet) and placed in a detention facility.

For the first 3 weeks, the historian was held in complete isolation without access to a lawyer. According to available reports, Dr. Kirpichyonok was subjected to hours-long interrogations (lasting 18-24 hours a day), sleep deprivation, and intense psychological pressure, which forced him into self-incrimination. Currently, the State Attorney's Office of Israel has filed an official indictment, incriminating him with "espionage" and "operating under the guidance of foreign intelligence" within a closed trial.

In an escalation of the situation, on October 12, at 8:00 AM, SHABAK agents arrested the lawyer of Dr. Kirpichyonok -- Inna Leybedinskaya-Katz, criminalizing her professional activity under the pretext of "contact with a foreign factor". On October 15, the court remanded her in custody and imposed a strict gag order (Tzav Issur Pirsum), completely banning domestic media coverage of her case.

Earlier, on September 24, the court extended the detention period of Dr. Kirpichyonok for another 2 months -- until November 24, refusing to lift the judicial censorship despite demands from the defense and Israeli media. On October 8, the High Court of Justice (BAGATZ) also refused to lift the judicial ban from the historian's case. He is currently being held in a solitary cell in Ayalon Prison under conditions that threaten his life. The Israel Prison Service (SHABAS) continues to unlawfully deny any meetings with the client.

Due to the refusal of medical care, the scholar's glaucoma has rapidly progressed, as a result of which he has completely lost sight in one eye, and his leg was seriously injured due to the constant presence in shackles during interrogations. In addition, the Israeli authorities denied the Russian embassy consular access to him, using his dual citizenship as a pretext. Now that his lawyer is in prison, the scholar is left completely defenseless in absolute isolation.

Kirpichenok's Book Israel: The Road to Catastrophe

There is every reason to believe that these accusations are directly related to his many years of public and academic activity, his research into the history of Zionism, and his critique of the Israeli government's policies. His books, including “A People's History of Israel” and “Israel: The Road to Catastrophe”, were based entirely on open sources and archival materials.

Reports on his persecution have already been published by World Socialist Web Site, the Rabkor.ru media resource, the Latin American television network teleSUR, the independent platform CounterPunch, and the Arabic service of the Russian television network RT.

The UN Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights registers an appeal

The international human rights network Scholars at Risk has logged this case into its Academic Freedom Monitoring Project. The United Nations Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR) has registered an appeal concerning the cases of Dr. Kirpichenok and Advocate Inna Leybedinskaya-Katz under Reference Number: 1bblaq2e. Domestically, the Association for Civil Rights in Israel (ACRI) has placed the situation under legal monitoring to evaluate potential intervention. Meanwhile, the Office of the State Comptroller and Ombudsman of Israel has rejected the complaint (Case No. 1254441 / MENTA:002110013847), declaring a total lack of jurisdiction over judicial matters.

I request you to familiarize yourselves with the detailed materials on the 8-language campaign website. On the website and via the links below, you can familiarize yourselves with the text and the list of those who have already signed the Open Letter in defense of Dr. Artyom Kirpichyonok.

To add your name to the list of signatories, please reply to this email or send your details (first name, last name, position/title, place of work, and country) to the following address: ArtemKirpichenok@gmail.com

Constantly updated campaign website (in 8 languages): https://sites.google.com/view/artem-kirpichenok

To sign or familiarize oneself with the Open Letter and the complete list of signatories: https://docs.google.com/document/d/118zoysAj4yzzGpDO1wSuQhTB8Yr9bHY8/edit?usp=sharing&ouid=115079145443591172567&rtpof=true&sd=true

Every media mention or dissemination of this information in academic, journalistic, and professional circles is of vital importance and serves as a call for immediate action in connection with the blow to academic freedom and the right to legal defense in Israel, as well as the salvation of the health and life of the scholar and his lawyer. Only continuous international pressure is capable of breaking through this blockade and saving lives.

Public statements and signatures under the open letter in defense of the scientist have already been made by: 

Judith Butler, philosopher and professor at the University of California,

Jean Bricmont, professor emeritus of physics at the Catholic University of Louvain, world-renowned essayist, and co-author of Noam Chomsky, Belgium; 

Vijay Prashad, director of the Tricontinental: Institute for Social Research, India/USA; 

Darko Suvin, professor emeritus at McGill University and fellow of the Royal Society of Canada, Canada; 

Felicia Pratto, professor of psychological sciences at the University of Connecticut, Sergey Baburin, Doctor of Law and former Deputy Chairman of the State Duma, Russian Federation; 

Anhar Kochneva, war correspondent, Lebanon; 

Yakov Rabkin, professor emeritus of history, Canada; 

Richard Silverstein, journalist and author of the Tikun Olam blog, USA; 

Tony Greenstein, journalist, author, and co-founder of the Palestine Solidarity Campaign, United Kingdom; 

Itamar Eichner, international correspondent, Israel; 

David Roediger, professor of African American Studies and American Studies at the University of Kansas, USA; 

Robin D. G. Kelley, professor of history at the University of California;

Vinay Lal, professor of history at the University of California,

Nika Dubrovsky, artist, writer, and founder of the David Graeber Institute, UK); 

Alex Tabarrok, Dr., director of the Center for Study of Public Choice at George Mason University, USA; 

Yevgenia Belorusets, artist and writer, Ukraine/Germany; 

Federico Fuentes, editor of LINKS International Journal of Socialist Renewal, Australia; and others.

Sincerely,
Yevhen Terekhov, Ph.D.