Saturday, 7 July 2012

Nazi Rabbi Shmuel Eliyahu to Head Israel's Red Cross (Magen David Adom)

The new head of the Israeli Red Cross (MDA) Rabbi Shmuel Eliyahu advocates killing 1 millions Palestinians

 Advocate of Genocide to Head Israel's Magen David Adom! (Red Cross)

When Henry Kisssinger received the Nobel Peace Prize, it was said by one comic to be beyond parody.  Israel has gone one further.  Shmuel Eliyahu, Chief Rabbi of Safed, son of Israel’s former Sephardic Chief Rabbi and the creature who called for people to refuse to rent rooms or flats to Arabs, has nonetheless been deemed fit to head Israel’s version of the Red Cross, the Magen David Adom.

And of enormous help in his battle to gain this prestigious prize was his advocacy of exterminating a million Palestinians.  Definitely a bonus when it comes to the fierce competition one naturally expects for such a post.  Of course the Palestinians he was talking about were those in Gaza who had fired ‘rockets’ at Israel and killed all of 20 people (cf. to about 8,000 Palestinians).

The obvious answer is to deregister MDA from the International Committee of the  Red Cross, but the ICRC is well used to supporting murderous regimes.  It visited Guantanamo and said not a word.  And during the war years, the ICRC’s record included sanitising Auschwitz (the Czech children’s camp was gassed soon after they left) and visiting the ‘model’ concentration camp of Thereinstadt in Czechoslovakia (most of its inmates were shipped to Auschwitz before the visit).  So they have a good record to live up to.  So Rabbi Shmuel Eliyahu will no doubt be given a generous welcome to the hall of villains.

One should also bear in mind the Talmudic injunction that one should not save a non-Jewish life on the Sabbath.  Although it is permitted to do so if that would endanger Jews (the non-Jews might feel peeved about it!) in the case of Israel this is not so since Palestinians (Amalek) are killed everyday by the State anyway.  So MDA is likely to end up in a situation where not only are sexes separated but there is different treatment for Jews and non-Jews.  After all dear reader, this is the Jewish State!

Tony Greenstein

Rabbi who called for slaughter of a million Palestinians is to supervise Israel’s ‘Red Cross’

A notoriously racist rabbi who once called on Israel to slaughter a million Palestinian civilians has been appointed to head a supervisory committee for Magen David Adom (MDA) – Israel’s equivalent of the Red Cross and Red Crescent.

Haaretz reported that under pressure from ultra-Orthodox Jewish groups MDA decided to set up a rabbinical committee to dictate religious guidelines – including gender relations – for volunteers in the rescue service.

The committee is headed by Rabbi Shmuel Eliyahu, the Chief Rabbi of Safad, whose salary is paid by the Israeli government. Eliyahu has a long, well-documented history of extreme racism and has called for violence against Palestinians.

Since 2006, Magen David Adom – whose name means Red Star of David – has been a full member of the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC), and is Israel’s internationally recognized agency for disaster management, ambulance service and blood banks.

The organization also raises tax-exempt donations in the United States through theAmerican Friends of Magen David Adom

‘Kill a million’

  • In 2007, Eliyahu advocated mass slaughter of Palestinians in order to deter rocket fire from Gaza, while defending a ruling by his late father that Israel was permitted to indiscriminately kill civilians. “If they don’t stop after we kill 100, then we must kill a thousand,” Shmuel Eliyahu advised, adding, “And if they do not stop after 1,000 then we must kill 10,000. If they still don’t stop we must kill 100,000, even a million. Whatever it takes to make them stop.”
  • Eliyahu has stated that the “seducing” of Jewish girls was “another form of war” by Arab men.
  • In 2010, Eliyahu and other state-employed rabbis issued a ruling telling Jews not to sell or rent property to members of the country’s Palestinian Arab minority, who make up a fifth of the population.
  • Eliyahu has led efforts to prevent Arab students from living in Safad, stating, “When a non-Jew moves in, residents begin to worry about their children, about their daughters. Many Arab students have been known to date Jewish girls.”
  • Eliyahu has publicly denigrated Arabs and Muslims, stating, “whenever I’m interviewed I ask the interviewer if they would want an Arab to live in their neighborhood.”

Violating neutrality and respect for international humanitarian law

As a member organization of ICRC, Magen David Adom is presumably committed to the mission of the ICRC:

The work of the ICRC is based on the Geneva Conventions of 1949, their Additional Protocols, its Statutes – and those of the International Red Cross and Red Crescent Movement – and the resolutions of the International Conferences of the Red Cross and Red Crescent. The ICRC is an independent, neutral organization ensuring humanitarian protection and assistance for victims of war and armed violence. It takes action in response to emergencies and at the same time promotes respect for international humanitarian law and its implementation in national law.

What could be more contrary to that mission than Israel’s MDA appointing Shmuel Eliyahu who not only defends and advocates mass, indiscriminate violence against civilians, but is a racist par excellence?

It should be recalled that there was a years long campaign by Israel and Zionist organizations to get MDA accepted into the ICRC. If MDA does not completely dissociate itself from, and condemn racist inciters like Eliyahu, perhaps it should be expelled.

Moreover, the Palestinian Red Crescent Society should review any cooperation with MDA

Magen David Adom sets up panel to dictate religious guidelines for volunteers

Under pressure from ultra-Orthodox, MDA sets up committee to be headed by Rabbi Shmuel Eliyahu, who raised controversy by calling on Jewish residents of Safed to not rent apartments to Arabs.

By Chaim Levinson    | Jun.25, 2012 | 2:24 PM |
An ultra-Orthodox female volunteer of Magen David Adom in Jerusalem. Photo by Jini
Rabbi Shmuel Eliyahu at a conference in Ramle. Photo by Nir Kafri
Israel's Magen David Adom has succumbed to pressure by ultra-Orthodox groups and decided to set up a rabbinical committee to dictate religious guidelines - including gender relations - for volunteers in the rescue service.

The committee, which was established under pressure from the Haredi community, as well as growing criticism from the religious Zionist movement, will be headed by Shmuel Eliyahu, the Chief Rabbi of Safed, as well as by a posek (a Jewish legal scholar) from the religious Zionists.

Eliyahu, who had undergone investigation on suspicion of incitement to racism, made headlines in 2010 when he called on Jewish residents of Safed not to rent apartments to Arabs. In a conference which took place last year, Eliyahu was recognized for his “actions, deeds and commitment for keeping a Jewish character in the Land of Israel.”

In contrast to other public organizations, until now, Magen David Adom (MDA) has not employed a permanent rabbi. Over the past few years, MDA has been under constant attack by the ultra-Orthodox public, which has complained of lack of modesty and the inappropriate mixing of men and women in the rescue service.

Most of the pressure is in the Jerusalem district, where there are many ultra-Orthodox workers, as well as many female volunteers in national service. More than 2,500 ultra-Orthodox people volunteer in MDA and other rescue services.

In February 2011, a rabbinical ruling by top Haredi rabbis forbade volunteering for MDA. “It is forbidden to volunteer for the organization, not even for the purpose of saving lives,” the ruling said. “Volunteering could, God forbid, lead to severe [Halakhic] infractions among the general leadership and the spiritual influence,” the ruling stated.

There are no current instructions regarding relations between the sexes. Nonetheless, in branches with many religious or ultra-Orthodox volunteers, voluntary separation is accepted. Thus, ambulance crews are made up entirely of men.

The committee, which began functioning several weeks ago, provides MDA with instructions regarding relations between sexes, information on science-related matters as well as other relevant issues. In one case, the committee ruled that MDA cannot evacuate anyone injured in an accident on the Sabbath to a hospital, as long as they request evacuation for insurance-related reasons.

The committee is also considering the possibility to establish rooms for men and women in MDA stations, so that volunteers of different sexes are not forced to spend the night together.

Rabbi Eliyahu confirmed the details for Haaretz. Magen David Adom has not provided a response.


  1. The blog Shoah..... writes "Nazi Rabbi who called for slaughter of a million Palestinians is to supervise Zio-Nazi ‘Red Cross’.
    But Your Blog..... goes even further with your out of space truth.....
    "Nazi Rabbi Shmuel Eliyahu to Head Israel's Red Cross (Magen David Adom)"......

    I guess you should open up a career as a Journalist, as your commitment to the truth, is just complete....

    For the readers...... Haaretz reported that under pressure from ultra-Orthodox Jewish groups MDA decided to set up a Rabbinical committee to dictate religious guidelines – including gender relations – for volunteers in the rescue service.
    The committee is headed by Shmuel Eliyahu.

    In the intellectual understanding of Greenstein......
    He became the HEAD OF ISRAEL MAGAEN DAVID......

    Lets see what Greenstein has to write about that, as he is never wrong......

  2. Red Cross representatives supporting the dispossession and disappearance of victims of racist regimes has a precedence -
    The deportation of Reich Jews began in mid-September 1941, the same month in which the Jews were visually identified with yellow stars of David to stigmatise them openly and deepen their isolation....The head of the German Red Cross, Kurt von Behr, was put in charge of distributing the Jews personal effects - bed and table linen, porcelain, dishes, silverware, furniture and household appliances - to the victims of British bombing.
    Michael Burleigh, Moral Combat: A History of World War II p436-7, 2010.

  3. "The new head of the Israeli Red Cross (MDA) Rabbi Shmuel Eliyahu advocates killing 1 millions Palestinians".....

    I wonder where you took this news from......

  4. Thank you for your recommendation of myself for a career in journalism. No life is too short thanks.

    Ha'aretz reports that a Rabbinical committee headed by Eliyahu will dictate religious guidelines and gender relations in the MDA. Clearly a person who has the abilityh to dictate to an organisation is its de facto leader, regardless of which supine bureaucrat has the official title.

    Brian asks where I took the story that Eliyahu has advocated the killing of a million Palestinians. Electronic Intifada, as you will find out if you click the headline and it in turn took it from the Jerusalem Post of 30.5.07. You can also find the quote on Wikipedia amongst other sources. Glad you admit its indefensible, hence you can't believe it is accurate. Unfortunately the sayings of this Nazi Rabbi are all too accurate.

    I should add that in the course of tracing the source I came cross some even more delightful sayings of the man who is dictating morals and ethics to MDA.

    How about the call by Eliyahu for 'revenge' including a call to 'hang children of Mercaz Harav gunman from tree.' Mercaz Harav is the Yeshiva (religious seminary) which is producing a whole new generation of Nazi Rabbis. Oh the source is Ha'aretz of 26th March 2008.

    Are you going to try and deny this like some sordid holocaust denier too?

    But Shmuel is only following in his father footsteps. Mordechai Eliyahu, former Sephardi Chief Rabbi Eliyahu ruled that there was "absolutely no moral prohibition against the indiscriminate killing of civilians during a potential massive military offensive on Gaza aimed at stopping the rocket launchings. The letter, published in Olam Katan [Small World], a weekly pamphlet to be distributed in synagogues nationwide this Friday, cited the biblical story of the Shechem massacre (Genesis 34) and Maimonides' commentary (Laws of Kings 9, 14) on the story as proof texts for his legal decision. According to Jewish war ethics, wrote Eliyahu, an entire city holds collective responsibility for the immoral behavior of individuals. In Gaza, the entire populace is responsible because they do nothing to stop the firing of Kassam rockets."

    That's from the JP of 30.5.07.

    Lovely people these rabbis. Didn't the Nazis also urge the same collective punishments against civilian populations? Clearly Israel has indeed become a 'light unto the nations'!!!

  5. "Brian asks where I took the story"

    Typical Greenstein..... I asked, where you got the news that he is the Head of Magen David.....
    Answer this question............

  6. Greenstein will not response to the LIE and will not admit he made up this headline.......
    He thinks that if he will fabricate a headline, the fools will accept it.
    How stupid can you be.

  7. I think these contributions are co-ordinated because it doesn't matter whether Eliyahu supervises what MDA does or heads it. What matters is that this Nazi Jewish war criminal is dictating the moral ethics to the MDA

    About this the Zionist trash posting here has nothing to say. They don't mind for a minute that a man who advocates murdering a million Palestinians heads the Zionist Red Cross.

    What pitiful and shameless apologists for mass murder you are. If you had lived in the 1940's you'd have been apologists for Eichman and Himmler, as of course the jewish Agency and the Zionist press played down or denied the reports of their crimes.

  8. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

  9. Joe seems to think that repeating a previous comment improves the point he is making. I've already made clear that

    i. Someone who can dictate morality and ethics to a national offshoot of the ICRC must surely be the head or the equivalent in the organisation, whomsoever is the bureaucratic head.

    ii. The real issue is not the status of Eliyahu, since his ability to dictate to Magen David Adom is acknowledged by all, but appointing an advocate of mass murder to have anything to do with such an organisation.

    Upon this Richards has nothing to say and if he is unable to defend or oppose it then there is nothing he has to say of any relevance.

    Or would we have appointed Hitler to take charge of the policy on medical ethics of a national mental health hospital for elderly Jews?

    So dear Zionist trolls, I shan't post anything that doesn't directly deal with the issue in the article.

    And in case you 'forgot' the issue it is, quite simply the report in Ha'aretz of 25th June:

    'Magen David Adom sets up panel to dictate religious guidelines for volunteers

    Under pressure from ultra-Orthodox, MDA sets up committee to be headed by Rabbi Shmuel Eliyahu, who raised controversy by calling on Jewish residents of Safed to not rent apartments to Arabs.'

    Oh and one other thing. I usually refer to people by their first name so Zionists are going to have to get used to being polite if they wish to post on this blog. This isn't the West Bank or South Africa where you refer to people by their surname! Just an exercise in the manners which most Zionists find difficult to acclimatise to


Please submit your comments below