14 January 2012

31 Disabled People Die Proving They're Unfit to Work

Liar, Liam Byrne MP, Shadow Work & Pensions Secretary 'Forgets' that New Labour Began the Attack on Claimants & the Disabled

As the article in the Scottish Herald shows, at least 31 people have died waiting to see if they are ill enough to retain their benefits. Some of them have literally been killed by the cuts made ‘necessary’ to ensure that the bankers, crooks and swindlers who run our system are allowed to continue as before.

Yet we have New Labour’s Liam Byrne in the Guardian on Monday ‘Labour urges radical rethink on welfare’ arguing for a tough line on welfare. No he wasn’t talking about the welfare that the bankers and fellow parasites have had lavished on them, or allowing Vodafone, News International and a host of other companies to avoid tax.

Like his war criminal predecessor Blair, this toughness was reserved for the unemployed and poor, whose fecklessness and laziness has caused them to be unemployed. Like the Tories and Liberal-Democrats, the poor are to be blamed for their own situation.

There is nothing that the Tories are now doing that New Labour didn’t begin before them. It was New Labour which originally proposed an attack on DLA (they proposed scrapping it and Attendance Allowance) for those 65 and over. It was of course New Labour that abolished Incapacity Benefit and introduced ESA. It ill behoves them to now complain the system is in a mess. Indeed much of the pioneering work for the Tories has come from New Labour’s Lord Hutton and Frank Field MP. Byrne himself suggests in his article A William Beveridge for this century's welfare state Byrne says that ‘housing benefit alone is costing the UK over £20bn a year. That is simply too high.’

The obvious answer to anyone on the Left is reduce rents, bring back rent controls. But that would affect the propertied classes. Instead he argues for the long-term unemployed to attend ‘a work or retraining centre’. In other words a new Workhouse. But when it comes to the Tory-Lib attacks on the disabled, Byrne simply lies. ‘I think Beveridge would have looked aghast at the government's plans to axe disability benefits.’ Perhaps he has forgotten New Labour’s record. More a case of selective amnesia for this former immigration minister.

Kate Devlin UK Political Correspondent

More than 30 benefits claimants have died while appealing against a judgment that they were fit to work, official figures show, leading to accusations the system is in chaos.

Tribunal centres across the UK, including in Scotland, are also being forced to hold Saturday sittings to deal with disputed cases, politicians have been told.

Last night Labour called on the Tory-LibDem Coalition at Westminster to get a grip on the situation before it spirals "completely out of control".

Almost four in 10 cases are currently overturned on appeal, a proportion campaigners say is unacceptable.

A series of written parliamentary answers has revealed the strain on the system. They show that centres around the country, including in Dundee, Hamilton, Cardiff, Plymouth and Wrexham, have been forced to hold Saturday sittings in recent months. Other centres, including Newcastle, South Shields, Leeds and Sheffield, are due to sit at weekends from this month.

In a parliamentary written answer, Chris Grayling, the Conservative minister, said 31 people had died while awaiting their appeal in the three years to last October.

Although there was no indication how they died, The Herald revealed earlier this year that two Scots who died while waiting to challenge their decision had died of the conditions that led them to apply for Incapacity Benefit in the first place.

The company responsible for assessing if disability or sickness claimants are fit to work is also struggling to meet demands to change its operations, the answers also show.

Atos, a French firm, is being paid £100 million a year by the Government as it seeks to cut the cost of incapacity benefit. But the company has faced growing criticism over its handling of the cases.

Following a report designed to reduce the number of incorrect assessments, Atos was told to put staff in job centres, where the final decisions are made. But Mr Grayling also admitted a shortage of resources meant that recommendation had yet to be implemented.

A telephone helpline was being introduced as an "interim arrangement until Atos is in a position to reintroduce the deployment of healthcare professionals in benefit centres", he said.

Since October 2008, all those applying for a new benefit, the Employment and Support Allowance, which is designed to replace incapacity benefit, have been assessed if they are fit to work.

In April last year Atos also began reassessing all those currently receiving incapacity benefit, following pilots in Aberdeen and Burnley.

If trends continue, there will be 240,000 appeals over this financial year – a rise of 30% on the previous year, and at a cost of £60m in administration alone.

Tom Greatrex, the MP who obtained the information, warned the system was in chaos.

Mr Greatrex, the MP for Rutherglen and Hamilton West, has highlighted the case of one of his constituents who was deemed fit to work despite suffering from Parkinson's and who eventually had his case overturned on appeal.
"The Tory-led Government must get a grip on this system before it spirals completely out of control," he said.

"The rocketing cost of appeals, the huge rise in the number of Tribunal judges, and the introduction of Saturday sittings add up to one thing: the Work Capability Assessment is unfit for purpose."

A spokeswoman for the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) said under the older incapacity benefit system a higher proportion of decisions, 50%, had been overturned on appeal.

Atos last night referred inquiries to the DWP.


  1. Nothing concerning Zionism.
    Not Interesting...............

  2. This blog is not a solely anti-Zionist one. It also says I'm a socialist and anti-racist and I do post, a minority of articles, on things other than Zionism.

    I make no apologies for carrying this article.

  3. Thanks for that, Tony. Nice to see someone cares.

    They're really plumbing new depths with this. I'm not sure what the exact position is now, but I heard they were going to let Atos hear the appeals too - also there was talk of withholding benefits (I assume not everything, but I wouldn't bank on it) while waiting for appeal; and of course, legal aid is now not available for benefits issues.

    The CAB report on the assessments for ESA showed that appeals that had some professional support (eg CAB) had a success rate of something like 70% as opposed to the 40% otherwise. So they hope to cut that down by removing support? Great.

    This whole process has built into it the acceptance that quite a large number of people, who are unable to look after themselves, are going to have their support removed, which means they die of course, and the rest have this hanging over them all the time - that someone at random or vindictively can just take their sustenance away and there's nothing they can do about it.

    Strikes me, and I don't think it's over-egging it, that this fits the UN definition of genocide - to attempt to destroy in whole or in part and identifiable group? If the current treatmnent of the disabled doesn't fit that, what does?

  4. I haven't heard about having Atos hear appeals. I very much doubt if even this lot would propose that you could be judge and jury in your own case. That would cause an uproar. That is why there is a tribunal system.

    Yes where you have representation your chances are much higher. Brighton Unemployed Centre has about an 80% success rate (and the average here is 60% too!).

    We need people to organise and get together. That is our problem as the unions are doing fuck all. We can but fight!

  5. I have sick clients having their DLA taken off them. No one seems to care. I don't know who is sicker, my clients or ATOS. At least my clients have an excuse though.

  6. Here's a good blog, with a lot of good links

    diary of a Benefit Scrounger

  7. 31 death waiting for judgement. not nice...

    Disabled Grant


Please submit your comments below