When the BBC's Tim Davie
says ‘We are absolutely driven by a passion for impartiality” it’s
like Hitler saying he was driven by a passion for Jews
Tim Davie Interview
We should celebrate a rare victory
over the BBC who have been forced to client climb down, reinstate and apologise
to Gary Lineker. If Lineker had spoken out in support of Cruella Braverman’s
abolition of the right to claim asylum and attacked refugees does anyone
seriously think that Lineker would have been suspended?
That is why, when Tim Davie, talks
about his ‘passion for impartiality’
he is a liar. Was Fiona Bruce suspended for defending Stanley Johnson’s ‘one-off’ breaking of his wife’s nose?
Was Jeremy Clarkson suspended when he said
that strikers should be shot, ‘in front
of their families’ no less?
The list of BBC pundits and
presenters who make right-wing comments without any action being taken against
them is legendary. But when Lineker spoke out in support of refugees and had the audacity to compare the vitriol
directed against them with the attacks on refugees in the 30s, both from the Mail and Express all hell broke loose. The Tory tabloids barked and Tim
Davie jumped to attention.
However Lineker stood his ground,
unlike the shameless cowards on Labour’s front bench who rushed to criticise
Lineker’s remarks.Yvette
Cooper and Lady Nugee (Emily Thornberry) like good Zionists condemned
the comparison with the 30s. Yet in the 30s the same attacks were made on
Jewish refugees to this country that the Tories make now. The Daily Mail wrote
on 20th August 1938 that:
“The way stateless Jews from
Germany are pouring in from every port of this country is becoming an
outrage: the number of aliens entering the country through back door
– a problem to which the Daily Mail has repeatedly pointed”
Let no one pretend that Britain has
a good record on refugees. It is bloody awful and the record of the Labour
Party is equally appalling.
The BBC was born in the womb of the
British state. For decades, until the 1990s. MI5 vetted its staff to
ensure that those deemed ‘subversive’ were excluded from employment.
In 1926 the BBC’s founder Lord
Reith excluded
the Archbishop of Canterbury from broadcasting to the nation because he
favoured a settlement with the miners during the General Strike whereas the
government sought to starve them back to work. The Catholic Archbishop of
Westminster was
allowed to broadcast because he condemned the strike as a sin against god.
Throughout its history the BBC has
distinguished itself by hostility to the working class and trade unions.
Whenever there is a strike they focus, not on the workers’ grievances but on
theimpact of the strike on the public. They
emphasise the inconvenience to the public not the struggle to get by of the
workers. They tell us the cost of meeting the workers’ demands but never the
cost of tax avoidance by the wealthy.
When was the last time the BBC questioned,
still less informed us, of the catastrophic effect of NHS privatisation? When
did they connect the PPE shortages at the start of the pandemic with the
outsourcing of contracts and the ‘just in time’ mentality of the companies
involved.
When was the last time the BBC
questioned the incompatibility of the profit motive and the mission of the NHS
to care for people regardless of cost?The BBC has the values of capitalism and the market embedded in
everything they say and do.
Not once do they ask, as with the
Post Office or the Railways why workers are expected to take pay cuts in real
terms when hundreds of millions of pounds go to shareholders. When they tell us
how much it costs to meet workers’ demands have they ever gone on to ask why
that cost could have more than been met by reducing dividend?
Jonathan Pie
The most
infamous case of BBC bias was during the 1984-5 Miners’ strike when they focused,
not on police violence but that of the miners.At Orgreave Coke Depot where there was mass picketing, the BBC reversed
the sequence of Police attacks on the miners and the miners retaliating by
throwing stones. The Police attacks were portrayed as a response to the Miners’
actions. Eventually the BBC owned up
but by then it was too late.
The
coverage of the gross corruption in the allocation of COVID contracts, with the
Tories having a VIP lane, whereby cronies and friends of Tory MPs and Ministers
gained preferential access, has been virtually nil. What is inconvenient to the
government is inconvenient to the BBC.
On Israel
and Palestine the BBC is a byword for bias. Israeli attacks on Palestinians are
always a reaction to Palestinian violence never the cause of such violence.
Watching the BBC you would never know that Palestinians in the West Bank have experienced
the rule of a military junta for over half a century. They speak of the Police
keeping order whilst not mentioning that this is a colonial police force that
is hostile to the Palestinians whilst protective of Jewish settlers.
When
demonstrators in Jerusalem were chanting ‘death
to the Arabs’ the Police attacked
the Palestinians who protested.Imagine
that there were Palestinian crowds shouting ‘death to the Jews’. It would
feature on every BBC news programme. But when Israelis chant ‘Death
to the Arabs’ it provokes no comment.
Last year a riot of settlers on Jerusalem Day, a veritable
pogrom, in East Jerusalem, was portrayed by BBC correspondent Yolande
Knell in this 44 second video clip,
as follows.
‘‘the
mood of them is jubilant, festive.It
feels like a party.... they’re celebrating their presence at this spot.’
This
video of last year’s march
shows a variety of racist slogans such as ‘Mohammed
is Dead’‘A Good Arab is a Dead
Arab’’The Arab is a son of a bitch. and of course ‘Death to the Arabs.’
BBC
reporters know that Jerusalem Day is a demonstration of Jewish Supremacism
whose purpose is to make it clear that the Palestinian presence in Jerusalem is
unwanted. Hence the reference in the above video to a second Nakba (ethnic
cleansing of Palestinians). Notice the reaction of the Police.
The
excuse made for Knell’s piece to camera, in response to my complaint, was that
it ‘should be
considered within the wider context of the article’ was pathetic. A visual piece to camera is clearly going to
have more impact than a written article on the BBC web site.
Andrew
Neil, who was a high profile political correspondent for the BBC and also chairman
of the tory Spectator hasn’t hesitated to air his opinions on Brexit,
Corbyn etc. without any come back.
Is it any wonder that the BBC behaves
in this way when its Chairman, Richard Sharp, donated £400,000 to the Tory party
while helping Boris Johnson, to secure loan of £800,000? We should treat the
BBC for what it is – an Establishment Broadcasting Corporation.
Fiona
Bruce defends Boris's dad breaking his wife’s nose – just a ‘one-off’
When Martine Croxall said she was ‘gleeful’ at the news that Boris Johnson had dropped out the Tory
leadership race and would not return to Number 10 she was taken off the air.
Not only
had Croxall said “Well, this is all very
exciting, isn’t it? Am I allowed to be this gleeful? Well, I am!” but later
she could be heard giggling and said: “Sorry!
I shouldn’t probably. I’m probably breaking some sort of terrible due
impartiality rule by giggling.”
Former
culture secretary Nadine Dorries said it was an example of “deep seated bias” within the BBC. Croxall was not only taken off
air following the comments but the BBC launched an “urgent” investigation, saying in a statement:
“It is imperative that we maintain the
highest editorial standards. We have processes in place to uphold our
standards, and these processes have been activated.”
Why has
there been no action against the anti-Corbyn presenters Laura Kuenssberg and
Fiona Bruce?
Throughout
the Corbyn era the BBC led with attacks on ‘Labour anti-Semitism’. Andrew Neil devoted
the whole of his Sunday politics in 2016 to attacking
Labour ‘anti-Semitism’.
The tone of the programme was set by the voice over which
asked:
‘Does Jeremy Corbyn support 4 causes like the
Palestinians or Stop the War mean he’s not tough enough when there are
allegations of anti-Semitism in Labour.’
There was
no explanation why supporting the Palestinians or opposition to war should mean
hostility to Jews, unless it is being suggested that Jews are war-like. Itself
an anti-Semitic assumption.
There was a 45 second rant from Wes Streeting on Labour
‘anti-Semitism’ followed by a 25 second response from James Schneider, a
Momentum supporter defending Corbyn but not saying much else.
John Mann, the Zionist MP and Chair of the so-called Parliamentary
Anti-Semitism Committee, who believes that boycotts of Israel are inherently anti-Semitic,
was given an uninterrupted 6 minutes and 4 seconds. In other words those
arguing that the LP was saturated with anti-Semitism had a mere 16 times as much
time as the person who defended Corbyn. At no point did Andrew Neil question
Mann’s assumptions of Labour ‘anti-Semitism’. It was taken for granted.
Mann wasn’t asked, at any stage, for any evidence to support
his arguments. Neil asked 6 questions, none of them probing.
The first was ‘is there
a problem with anti-Semitism in the Labour Party.’ An interviewer with any
sense of balance of fairness would have asked ‘Why do you say there is an anti-Semitism problem… ‘ or ‘what is the evidence for your assertion that…’
Mann engaged in empty rhetoric but provided not a scrap of
evidence for his assertions.
The second question was no better. It assumed there was a
problem of anti-Semitism. ‘Why has it
come back’ and his third question simply asked ‘why in the Labour Party. Again no challenge to the central thesis.
Neil’s fourth question referred to Corbyn’s ‘friends in
Hamas and Hezbollah’ which is a repetition of the media lies. Corbyn
chaired a meeting at which he referred to the speakers as ‘friends’ in a general
and polite sense. That was all. They weren’t his personal friends.
In any event neither organisation is anti-Semitic.
Neil then suggested that Corbyn shared platforms with people
hostile to Israel and whether that is anti-Semitic. The assumption being that hostility
to the Zionist state is anti-Semitic.
His fifth question was no different. Are you doing enough about this. Again the assumption that there
was Labour ‘anti-Semitism’.
But it was Neil’s 6th question which was most
ironical. Andrew Neil demonstrated that
the only problem with anti-Semitism lies with people like himself. He
asked about the ‘Jewish vote’ as if there is a block Jewish vote to begin with.
Another irony is that when Andrew Neil was Editor of the
Sunday Times who did he hire
to verify
the Goebbels Diaries? Holocaust denier David Irving!
And when Boris Johnson was Editor of The Spectator he hired
Taki, the owner of Takis magazine for whom David Duke of the KKK wrote. Taki
supported the openly Nazi Golden Dawn Party in Greece. And who was Chairman of the Board of Press Holdings Media Group which owns The
Spectator? Andrew Neil! The hypocrisy is endless.
Taki himself was deeply anti-Semitic. As his biography records:
Taki was able to run columns on ‘bongo bongo land’,
West Indians ‘multiplying like flies’ and one on the world Jewish conspiracy,
in which he described himself as a ‘soi-disant anti-Semite’.
So where
are the left-wing reporters and news journalists at the BBC?We have Tory Laura Kuensberg and Nick Robinson,
ex-President
of the Oxford University Conservative Association.
Former
communications officer for Theresa May, Robbie Gibb, is on the BBC board. Tim
Davie, the current BBC director general, previously stood as a councillor for
the Tory Party in Hammersmith and was deputy chair of Hammersmith & Fulham Conservative
party.
The
question Davie has repeatedly failed to answer was why was Lineker silenced for
a tweet criticising the current government when it had no issues with Lineker’s
political views when he opened the BBC coverage of the Qatar World Cup with a
monologue detailing human rights issues in the Arab country? Impartiality, it
would seem, is only relevant when criticising policies of the Conservative
party.
Under the
heading of ‘impartiality’ the BBC has neglected to cover the scandal of our
sewage-filled waterways. Corporate vandalism is never a good story.
The BBC’s
coverage of Ukraine has been lamentable. When the Nord Stream pipelines were
blown up the BBC highlighted
US and Ukrainian accusations
that the Russians had blown up their own pipelines. A child of 6 could have
told them this was unlikely given that the Russians owned it. But if your
‘impartiality’ guidelines dictate you support NATO’s narrative then the absurd
becomes true.
The BBC
has failed to so much as mention the revelations
of Seymour Hersh, the legendary Pulitzer prize winning reporter, that it was
the United States that carried out the bombing of the Nordstream pipeline.
And then
there is Jeremy Corbyn. Who can forget the lying dishonest production by John
Ware, Is Labour Anti-Semitic?
In Liverpool Riverside Jewish
member Helen Marks was under investigation. Her investigator was Ben Westerman
who alleged that Rica Bird had asked him ‘where
are you from? Are you from Israel?
What Rica had said was ‘‘so I’m just curious about what branch are
you in?’ and when Westerman said it wasn’t relevant Rica accepted it. There
is a world of difference between asking what Labour Party Branch someone is in
and asking if someone Jewish is from Israel.
The interview was recorded
so it is clear that Westerman was lying. As the Labour Files rightly said, the Jews interviewed in the Panorama
programme were drawn entirely from the officers of the anti-Corbyn Jewish
Labour Movement. Not one Jewish anti- Zionist was interviewed. Another example
of BBC impartiality!
Rica Bird
Lord Sugar of The Apprentice has a history of political
outbursts including interviews calling on people to vote Conservative to
tweeting a mocked-up image of Corbyn sitting
next to Adolf Hitler. But ‘passionate’ Tim Davie was unmoved by such bias.
Given Tim Davie is so ‘passionate’
about impartiality there is a long list of issues that he could tackle. The
first could be the sycophantic
coverage of the deaths
of the Queen and Prince Philip. Endless interviews with the queues to see her
coffin. Given around a quarter of the British people are Republican why is
there no balance on theRoyal Parasites?
We could ask why Nigel Farage has made so
many appearances on Question Time. As the Scottish National reported
in May 2019:
IN a completely unsurprising
turn of events, the BBC
has come under fire over its lack of impartiality.
Last night's episode of
Question Time marked Nigel Farage's 33rd appearance on the show.
The
third-largest Westminster party was of course not represented on the
broadcaster's flagship political show.
It is clear that the BBC has always had a racist agenda. Why
else put Farage on Question Time so much? UKIP and the Brexit Party never son a
single parliamentary seat. This is the clue to the action taken against Gary
Lineker. The BBC is a thoroughly racist institution that thinks a few token
Black presenters will overcome its racist agenda.
Not forgetting Andrew Marr who, when Blair launched an
unprovoked war of aggression against Iraq outdid himself.
Mr Blair is well aware that all
his critics out there in the party and beyond aren’t going to thank him,
because they are only human, for being right when they’ve been wrong...
it would be entirely ungracious
even for his critics not to acknowledge that tonight he stands as a larger man
and a stronger Prime Minister as a result.
We all
know how that turned out! Researchers at John Hopkins University and the
Lancet, estimated that more
than a million people died as a result of the war. The BBC naturally ignored
these findings.
It was no
surprise that Marr’s book
launch for Head of State, was
held in Downing Street with David Cameron as the host.
Liz
Thomson, breached
the bonhomie and etiquette when she asked Marr if having Cameron host the book
launch ‘mightn’t compromise his position
as impartial political interviewer for the BBC’.
Marr’s
wife, Guardian columnist Jackie Ashley went ballistic telling Thomson that ‘you’ve ruined my evening’ before she ‘resumed the harangue, calling [Thomson]
‘despicable’ and ‘a B-I-T-C-H’.
The BBC
has reported the Ukrainian resistance but during the Iraq invasion there were
no favourable reports of the Iraqi resistance or the American
atrocities that Wikileaks revealed. Nothing on the thousands
of deaths in Falluja. To this day the BBC has ignored the kidnapping of
Julian Assange, who did the job that the BBC failed to do. Investigate American
war crimes.
So when
Tim Davie says he is ‘passionate’ about
BBC impartiality my only response is ‘pass
the sick bucket Alice.’
If Goebbels
were alive today he would be proud of how the BBC’s Ros Atkins has sanitised the neo-Nazi Azov Battalion
Hitchens pokes fund at how little Ros Atkins actually knows about neo-Nazism in Ukraine or anywhere else - Atkins is just an apologist for Azov and Ukraine's 'democratic' Nazis
Goebbels would be proud of the way in which the BBC's Ros Atkins has
whitewashed Ukraine's neo-Nazis
It never ceases to amaze me that the left has never made an
issue of the BBC license fee, which is the most regressive of all taxes. It currently stands at £159. However rich or
however poor you are you pay the same amount. For someone over 24 Job Seekers
Allowance is £77 pw, so the license fee is two full weeks of income plus a bit.
Richard Sharp - Islamaphobe and Tory Donor - who is BBC Chair
Compare this to the
Chairman of the BBC, Richard Sharp, a man whose salary is £160,000 per year for
a 3 day week. Leaving aside his other income, after tax he ‘earns’ £94,122, i.e. £1,810 per week. The license fee is 8.78% of
one week’s salary.
This interview on RT has disappeared from
most of social media. With difficulty I found it on Rachel Swindon's Twitter feed.
But it’s not simply the unfairness of the tax. The real problem
is that the BBC is in the words of John Pilger ‘the most refined propaganda service in the world’. RT has been silenced by Facebook.
To Palestinians the BBC is the ‘Voice of Israel’. It consistently portrays Israeli
violence as ‘retaliation’ against Palestinian violence by ignoring the reality
of Israel’s Occupation (a word that it never uses). It is a replay of the old Western
movies where the Red Indians used to attack, for some unknown reason, those
peaceful cowboys.
The BBC rarely reports the ongoing settler violence against the
Palestinians. Only when a Jewish settler is killed is violence reported. The
BBC is incapable of calling Israeli violence cold blooded murder.
The BBC rarely reports confiscation i.e. theft of Palestinian
land and when it does it provides no background by showing that this
is an ongoing process.
I have therefore penned an Open Letter to BBC Chair, Richard
Sharp.
Tony Greenstein
Strangely enough all these stories have disappeared - needs must
Dear Mr Sharp,
I want to explain why
I have no intention of paying a BBC license fee which pays your £160,000
salary. Given that you are reputed to be worth
a mere £100 million I suspect you won’t be going to bed hungry tonight, unlike
many of your viewers.
Since 2002 you have
also been a director
of the Centre for Policy Studies – a right-wing think tank founded by Thatcher.
The first duty
of the BBC Board, to which you were appointed
in February 2021, is to ‘Uphold and
protect the independence of the BBC.’ Who could possibly be more suitable than
a Tory Investment Banker and Islamaphobe who donated
over £400,000 to the Tories? Among those who appointed you was Catherine
Baxendale, who gave
a trifling £50,000 to the Tory party.
Steve Sweeney –
Morning Star interview Vanessa Beeley
A good example of your
political neutrality was the £35,000 you gave
to the Home Office ‘charity’ Quillam.
The reasons you gave for this largesse were that you were impressed
by Majid
Nawaz and his efforts to combat ‘radicalism and extremism.’
Majid
Nawaz and his conspiracies about a global palace coup
Those of a more
cynical mind might suggest that Majid Nawaz, who even LBC booted for his QAnon conspiracies about COVID and how the US election
was ‘stolen’ from Trump, was the personification of ‘radicalism and extremism’ . He believed that vaccinations were the product of “a
global palace coup that suspends our rights… by a network of fascists who seek
a New World Order”
The Azov Battalion may have dropped their insignia but their politics remain the same - the BBC notwithstanding
Quillam received over $1
million from the John
Templeton Foundation between 2014 to 2017. This Foundation works
with right-wing
Islamaphobic organisations with close ties to extreme right- Christian
networks.
Templeton and his wife
donated more than $1 million to Let
Freedom Ring, so that it could campaign against gay
marriage and contributed to “The Gathering” which promotesa “family values” agenda such as opposition to gay and
reproductive rights. This is as well as financing climate denier groups such as the
Atlas Economic Research Foundation
and pro-war neo-conservative groups like the American
Enterprise Institute.
According to Ros Atkins there are no neo-Nazis in Ukraine's army - Eduard Dolinsky, leader of Ukraine's Jewish community disagrees
Quillam drew up for MI5 a secret list which accused
peaceful Muslim groups, politicians and media of sharing the ideology of
terrorists. Groups included on this McCarthyist list included the Muslim Safety Forum and the Islamic Human Rights
Commission. Quillam’s briefing document said:
"The ideology of non-violent
Islamists is broadly the same as that of violent Islamists; they disagree only
on tactics.’
This was based on the theory that ‘non-violent extremism’ had
given birth to terrorism rather than such minor matters as the war in Iraq and
the bombing of Libya. This crackpot theory was as good a way as any of
demonising a whole community yet you saw fit to support.
Quillam
staged the fake ‘deradicalisation’ of Tommy Robinson and Kevin Carroll in
2013. They had allegedly left the EDL. Quilliam director Haras Rafiq then lied to a Parliamentary Select Committee
by denying that Quilliam had no “formal
business relationship with Tommy Robinson.” It later transpired that
Quilliam had been paying Robinson £2,000 a month, as Robinson
later admitted. See:
It’s quite
an impressive record for an organisation dedicated to combatting radicalism and
extremism.
As the
Jewish Chronicle proudly proclaimed, you are the BBC’s third Jewish
Chairman. It is reasonable to assume, having been an adviser to Boris Johnson, who combines racism,
anti-Semitism and Zionism, that like most rich right-wing Jews, you are also a
Zionist.
You
have continued the BBC’s uncritical support for Israel. At the end of May Yolande
Knell said
of thousands of far-right settlers chanting ‘death
to the Arabs’ as they invaded East Jerusalem that
Yolande Knell – the BBC’s grinning monkey praises Jewish pogromists
‘the mood of them is jubilant, festive.It feels like a party.... they’re celebrating
their presence at this spot.’
But it’s
not just the BBC’s bias on Israel that renders its claim to impartiality an
egregious lie. Ever since Russia’s invasion of Ukraine the BBC has functioned
as a NATO Broadcasting Corporation.
The BBC
has a bias against understanding. It always fails to give the background to the
events it reports. That was true of the Troubles in Ireland until it was embarrassed into commissioning a series on Irish history by Robert Kee. What
the BBC has never done is commission a similar series on the Zionist
colonisation of Palestine.
The Wolfangel which the Azov Battalion simply reverse - but to Ros Atkins it was simply decoration
Ukraine stands
out as an example of how the BBC has
jettisoned any claim to ‘due impartiality’. As John Pilger wrote you have
misrepresented events in
Ukraine as a malign act by Russia - when, in fact, the fascist led coup in
Ukraine was the work of the United States, aided by Germany and Nato.
This inversion of reality is
so pervasive that Washington's military encirclement and intimidation of Russia
is not contentious. It's not even news, but suppressed behind a smear and scare
campaign of the kind I grew up with during the first cold war.
The
suppression of the truth about Ukraine is one of the most complete news
blackouts I can remember. The biggest Western military build-up in the Caucasus
and Eastern Europe since world war two is blacked out. Washington's secret aid
to Kiev and its neo-Nazi brigades responsible for war crimes against the
population of eastern Ukraine is blacked out.
This
is an interview about the Ukrainian neo-Nazis penchant for chopping off heads,
ISIS style. As far as the BBC is concerned this interview never happened.
It is remarkable how neo-Nazis are now accepted in the White House and by the BBC
This was
written in 2014, yet you chose not to report US funding of the Maiden coup or
US military aid to neo-Nazi groups. The BBC has deliberately obscured the
origins of the war that is now taking place in order to paint Russia as the mainif not only culprit.
All of the
‘experts’ the BBC interviews coincidentally happen to be from the same pro-NATO
think tanks. If the BBC even made a stab at impartiality how could it fail to
interview John Mearsheimer of Chicago University, the Dean of
the Realist School of Political Science who sees the breaking of Western promises
to Gorbachev in 1991 over NATO expansion in Eastern Europe as the principal
cause of Russia’s invasion?
John Mearsheimer Lecture 16 June 2022
As
Professor Nicolas Guilhot said Mearsheimmer is an ‘irritant to
the Washington Foreign Policy Establishment.’ And what irritates the
Masters of War in Washington irritates the BBC too. Yet the BBC has no problem interviewing
war criminals like Kissinger and Blair. As Guilhot remarked we are in an ‘intellectual no fly
zone.’
Pilger interview on RT the BBC is part of the
established order in Britain
The BBC
was born in the womb of the British Establishment. Lord Reith, its first
Chairman, ensured that the BBC supported the government during the 1926 General
Strike by banning the Archbishop of Canterbury from broadcasting.
Unlike the Archbishop of Westminster, whose statement was broadcast, he refused
to condemn the strike as a sin against God.
Pilger referred to two studies of the BBC’s coverage
of the run-up to the invasion of Iraq by the University of Wales and Media
Tenor which found that the BBC’s coverage overwhelmingly reflected the Blair
government’s propaganda, including its lies about WMD. Less than 2% of BBC
reporting in this period allowed dissenting voices, despite a majority of
British people opposing the invasion.
George Bush condemns the 'wholly unjustified'
invasion of Iraq before correcting himself! Even Bush can see the comparison
with the US’s invasion of Iraq. However the BBC cannot!
What a contrast
to the BBC’s hostility to Russia’s invasion. The parallels between the 2
invasions were obvious, even to George Bush, the author of the Iraq war, when
in a Freudian slip he condemned ‘the
wholly unjustified invasion of Iraq’ before correcting himself.
The BBC
has completely ignored the 8 year war on the Donbas by Ukraine’s neo-Nazi militia,
A war that killed 14,000 people. See How ‘eastern Ukraine’ was lost.
Andrew Marr praising Blair for having got the
Iraq War right
On 9
April 2003, BBC political editor Andrew Marr stood outside 10 Downing Street and declared:
Mr Blair is
well aware that all his critics out there in the party and beyond aren’t going
to thank him, because they are only human, for being right when they’ve been
wrong...
it
would be entirely ungracious even for his critics not to acknowledge that
tonight he stands as a larger man and a stronger Prime Minister as a result.
Andrew Marr demonstrating his political impartiality
Well we
all know how that turned out! Researchers at John Hopkins University and the
Lancet, estimated that more than a million people died
as a result. The BBC ignored these findings.
The BBC
has reported the Ukrainian resistance but during the Iraq invasion there was no
such reports of the Iraqi resistance or the American atrocities that Wikileaks revealed. Nothing on
the thousands of deaths in Falluja. To this day the BBC has
ignored the kidnapping of Julian Assange, who did the job that you didn’t do.
Andrew Marr is 'congenial' - in other words always willing to help US imperialism sell its case
The BBC has
pride of place in the eyes of US neoconservatives as a cable from the US
embassy demonstrated when London Ambassador Sussman told
Hillary Clinton:
I hope you can
take some time out to tape an interview with leading British journalist Andrew
Marr.... It would be a powerful way for you to set out our priorities for
Afghanistan/Pakistan, and underline our premier partnership with the United
Kingdom. Marr is a congenial and knowlegable interviewer who will offer maximum
impact for your investment of time.
So loved
is Marr by the political elite that his book launch for Head of State, was held in Downing Street with David Cameron as the
host.
Liz
Thomson, breached the bonhomie and etiquette when she
asked Marr if having Cameron host the book launch ‘mightn’t compromise his position as impartial political interviewer for
the BBC’.
Marr’s wife,
Guardian columnist Jackie Ashley went ballistic telling Thomson that ‘you’ve ruined my evening’ before she ‘resumed the harangue, calling [Thomson]
‘despicable’ and ‘a B-I-T-C-H’.
According to the BBC the fellows above are liberals in disguise
Normalising
NATO’s neo-Nazi friends
When Putin
declared that his war aims included the deNazification of Ukraine, the BBC
decided to whitewash the Azov Battalion who had been occupying Mariupol and attacking
the Donbas for 8 years.
Steve Sweeney, International Editor
of the Morning Star explained after having come back from Lviv in the West, the
city is full of fascists of all stripes and
mercenaries. You won’t see this kind of interview on the BBC
The 'Jewish' Zelensky awarding the neo-Nazi head of Right Sector Ukraine's highest award - Atkins didn't get round to telling us about this!
Ros
Atkins, in an uninterrupted monologue, whitewashed the latest version of
the ‘moderate’ rebels that we saw in Afghanistan and Syria. Atkins asserted
that their incorporation into Ukraine’s National Guard had de-Nazified them
when it is far more likely that they polluted those around them. This was how
Hitler Nazified the German state.
After all, when you place a rotten apple in a barrel you don't expect it to become fresh as a result!
Arsen Avakov, the Fascist Interior Minister that Zelensky allowed to place neo-Nazis in senior police and security positions
Atkin’s
comment that Ukraine’s National Guard ‘was
under government command’ begs the question, so what?
The
National Guard was formed by Arsen Avakov, the fascist
Interior Minister and friend of Andrei Biletsky, the founder of Azov.
Zelensky nonetheless
kept Avakov on until July 2021 when he was replaced by Denys Monastyrsk, a ‘protege
of Avakov.’
Belarusian
neo-Nazi Serihy Korotkykh, the “Botsman,” who is suspected of masterminding the Bucha massacre, was close to Avakov. Korotkykh founded the
Russian far-right National Socialist Society. According to his Ukrainian asset
declarations,
Korotkykh worked as the head of the Interior Ministry’s Police Department for
the Security of Strategic Objects from 2015 to 2018.
‘National
Corps figures routinely visit the regiment, and the party’s ideologists lecture
Azov troops. Their blogs are published on the regiment’s site, while Azov’s
social media pages promote the National Corps.”
Zelensky is Jewish but he is also a Zionist and like Israel he finds Ukraine's neo-Nazis congenial
How did
Atkins achieve his objective? By pretending that Azov’s neo-Nazi origins were
in the past. Atkins asserted that:
i.Zelensky is Jewish
but he failed to mention that he is a Zionist.
Zionists have a record of forming alliances with neo-Nazis. Israel’s has long supplied
arms to the Azov Battalion.
ii.The main far right candidate in the 2019 election got 1.6% which was
irrelevant since they occupied key positions in the security state.
iii.In 2014 it was ‘under pressure
from Putin’ that the democratically elected Yakunovych backed out of an
agreement with the EU. Strangely enough there was no mention of the role of
Victoria Nuland, US Secretary of State and US funding of the fascist militias who killed over 100 demonstrators.
iv.Yakunovych fled to Russia with no mention of the armed neo-Nazi
militias that staged the coup (see Oliver Stone’s Ukraine on Fire).
According to Ros Atkins these neo-Nazis are a figment of our imagination
v.Putin annexed Crimea and backed separatists in parts of Eastern
Ukraine. Yes but Russian troops were not involved in the civil war caused by the
abolition of Russian language rights in a population, 40% of whom speak
Russian. No mention was made of the 90% of Crimea’s population who supported
joining Russia.
vi.The Wolfsangel which the Azov militia wears is not considered a fascist
symbol by Ukrainians. It was the symbol of SS divisions such as Das Reich.
According to Reporting Radicalism
‘Modern
neo-Nazis use it as a symbol of resistance. It is one of the most common
neo-Nazi symbols and is widely used by the far right in various countries as an
indicator of Nazi, neo-Nazi, and racist views... including the American
neo-Nazi terrorist organization, the Aryan Nation.
Atkins
failed to mention:
i.The Leaked conversation between Nuland and US
Ambassador Geoffrey Pyatt, which proves that the US was actively involved in forming
Ukraine’s post-coup government.
Vadim Troyan - a neo-Nazi appointed as Head of the Kyev Police
ii.The penetration at the highest levels of the Ukrainian state by
neo-Nazis. In 2014 Vadim Troyan, a founder of the fascist Patriot of Ukraine
and former Deputy Commander of Azov, was appointed Head of the Kyev Police. He
was appointed by the Interior Minister Arsen Avakov, who had a history of
appointing fascists to senior positions in the Ukrainian state.
iii.That the founder of the Azov Brigade, Andriy Biletsky once wrote that Ukraine’s mission is
to “lead the White Races of the world in
a final crusade…against the Semite-led Untermenschen.” Atkins argued that
Biletsky had left to form the National Corps and was therefore no problem.
iv.That in October/November
2017, according to a Home Office document70% of conscripts did not show up for duty. Young Ukrainians refused to
fight in the Donbas and preferred emigration.
v.That Azov’s symbolism remains unchanged from the days of Biletsky, the
Nazi Wolfsangel, supposedly an intersection
of the letters N and I, for “National Idea.” This was also the logo of Patriot
of Ukraine.
Unfortunately Zelensky lost the clash and the war continued
vi.That Zelensky Made Peace with Ukraine’s
Neo-Nazi Paramilitaries after he had surrendered to their demands to abandon Minsk 2, which
the Ukraine government had negotiated, in the face of death threats, after his meeting at Zolote in 2019. Minsk 2 would have granted federal rights to the Donbas within a unified Ukraine. The fascists rejected this. For example:
“Mr. President thinks he is immortal.” Fedyana said: “A grenade may explode there, by chance. And it would be the nicest if
this happened during Moscow’s shelling.’
vii.That in 2019 Zelensky met with a
range of fascist groups telling reporters “Everyone
was there – the National Corps, Azov, and everyone else.” A few seats away
was Yehven Karas, leader of the neo-Nazi C14 gang.
Eduard Dolinsky, the leader of Ukraine's Jewish community on the anti-Semitism that Ros Atkins says doesn't exist
viii.How in 2019 Zelensky defended Ukrainian footballer
Roman Zolzulya against Spanish fans taunting him as a “Nazi.” Zolzulya had posedbeside photos of Stepan Bandera and openly supported Azov. Zelensky, described Zolzulya as “a true
patriot.” Zelensky’s Jewishness is irrelevant. He has thrown his lot in with Ukraine’s
neo-Nazis.
ix.There was no mention by Atkins of the fact that Ukraine is the only country in the world to have a national holiday in memory of a Nazi
collaborator, Stepan Bandera. Bandera is no ordinary collaborator. He and his Ukraine
Insurgent Army (UPA) were responsible for the death of 200,000 Jews and 100,000 Poles.
‘Most of the
(Polish) victims were women and children (who) were tortured before being
killed; some of the methods included rape, dismemberment or immolation, among others.
x.On January 22, 2010 Ukrainian President Viktor Yushchenko made Bandera a “Hero of Ukraine.” It was Victor
Yakunovych, who the United States helped overthrow, who reversed this decision.
xi.According to The Forward, the oldest Jewish paper in
the United States, in 2014 after the Maidan coup, ‘the country has been erecting monuments to Nazi collaborators and
Holocaust perpetrators at an astounding pace — there’s been a new plaque or
street renaming nearly every week.’ What was the ‘Jewish’Zelensky’s reaction? “Stepan Bandera is a hero for a certain part of Ukrainians, and this is
a normal and cool thing. He was one of those who defended the freedom of
Ukraine.’
Atkins,
who parades as an expert on Ukrainian neo-Nazism, must have been aware of this.
The only conclusion one can draw Mr Sharp is that the BBC is happy employing an
apologist for Ukrainian neo-Nazism as a broadcaster.
To not
even mention how Ukraine’s neo-Nazis forced Zelensky to abandon his 2019
election platform to secure a peaceful solution of the crisis in the Donbas, is
as good example as any of the BBC’s political dishonesty.
Atkins
accepted that in 2015 Azov acknowledged that 10-20% of its members held
neo-Nazi views and that the degree of nazi views was ‘impossible to verify’ Yet Atkins dismissed this as ‘irrelevant because Azov was now part of
Ukraine’s National Guard.’
Peter
Hitchens summed this up as ‘bilge... minimising the importance of
neo-Nazis in Ukraine ('only' 20% of one Ukrainian Army unit are neo-Nazis, so
that is all right).’ According to Atkins, even if Azov
did have Nazi habits they ‘were just good
fighters’.
‘Context is vital here’ said Atkins when suggesting that
Azov was 1000 strong. This is a lie as Mariupol demonstrated. According to
Stanford’s Center for International Security and
Cooperation in 2019
Azov had 22,500 followers (20,000 National Corps members, 1500 Azov Regiment,
1000 National Militia). Today it is far in excess of that. Atkins’ assertion
that Azov is ‘a tiny fraction of the
Ukrainian military’ is another BBC lie.
Centuria is the West's major training hub for Ukraine's armed forces - but according to the BBC nothing is amiss
Atkins
said that Azov is ‘not the same force as
in 2014’. For once Atkins was telling the truth. Clearly it has grown
stronger and far better equipped whilst losing nothing of its original
ideology.
Atkin’s allegation
that the original core had been ‘drowned
out by the mass of newcomers’ is without foundation. It is speculation
and wishful thinking. If a group of state-funded neo-Nazis enters an already far-right
environment, the opposite is going to occur – namely that the rest of the
barrel will become rotten. See Azov
Battalion
There was no mention by Atkins of the Report Far Right
Group Made Its Home in Ukraine’s Major Military Western Training Hub from
George Washington University’s Institute
for European, Russian and Euroasian Studies. Why was evidence of the
adoption of neo-Nazis by the main Ukrainian State training centre ignored by
Atkins? Centuria consists of the traditional officer corps yet they have adopted the ideas of symbols of Ukraine's neo-Nazis.
In celebration of International Women’s Day NATO’s Twitter account celebrated the “remarkable women of Ukraine” with a photo of a woman in military
gear with a patch of the Nazi “Black Sun” on her uniform. It was quickly deleted when critics seized on it.
NATO was forced to delete this tweet as the woman in the picture is wearing a neo-Nazi symbol
The woman on the bottom right is wearing the Nazi symbol a Black Sun but that's ok by the BBC
Atkins referred
to the wearing of White Supremacist symbols saying that there is ‘no evidence such sentiments are widespread’.
Has Atkins not heard of Ukraine preventing Black people boarding buses out of
Ukraine and turning back Black people at its borders? Perhaps
he should consult this news story ‘Nigeria condemns
treatment of Africans.’ It is after all on the BBC’s own website.
This sign is on display outside Azov's Kyev Base - if it were a hammer and sickle does anyone think it would last a day?
According to the Intercept’s Seth Harp at the end
of June, the Azov Battalion’s base on the outskirts of Kyev was crawling with
neo-Nazis and White Supremacists.
‘It also has far more autonomy than any other
regiment of the army. “Azov is growing,” Maksym Zhorin, the commander of an
Azov special operations unit in Kyiv, told me in April. “Our emphasis is on the
future.... Also, who knows who was responsible for it, but “WHITE POWER” was
spray-painted on the kiosk right in front of us, alongside the driveway — in
English.'
The BBC's Ros Atkins failed to mention this little get together!
But it’s
not only the Azov Battalion. Bellingcat reported that on October 13 2019 photographs circulated
on social media showing Prime Minister Oleksiy Honcharuk on stage at a
“Veterans Strong” concert in Kyiv organized by Andriy Medvedko a far-right
member of C14 accused of murder headlined by a neo-Nazi band. Sokyra Peruna,
whose swastika-like logo is behind Honcharuk.
‘The Prime Minister wasn’t the only cabinet member
from Ukraine’s new government to be there — the Minister of Veteran Affairs, Oksana Koliada, joined Prime Minister
Honcharuk at the concert, and even promoted the event in a Facebook post (archive) the day before it took place.’
The
episode is a further example of how Ukraine’s far-right continues to be
normalized by top leaders in the country. Not only are Ukraine’s top ministers
attending events organized by far-right figures, they have also had a literal
seat at the table with Zelenskyy... Simultaneously, far-right organizations
across Ukraine have taken the lead in organizing “No capitulation!” protests
against Zelenskyy’s soon-to-be-launched talks with Russia...’
i.repeated the story about Russia bombing a maternity hospital in Mariupol.
Patrick Harrington’s interview with the Matron of the hospital told a different
story. Azov forces had evicted the patients before setting up base. Atkins said
that ‘there’s no evidence that Azov was
based there or that it was a military facility’. What more evidence does he
need? When the Israelis claims that hospitals in Gaza are Hamas bases the BBC
accepts that without question. Why?
ii.Atkins assertion that ‘Putin has
the reasons to do this but he doesn’t have the facts’. Nor it would seems does
the BBC’s Ross Atkins. Or if he does he chooses not to use them.
iii.When Atkins said that ‘Nazis
don’t hold Ukrainians hostage, they’re not launching attacks on Ukrainians’
he ignored the 8 year war on the Donbas by Azov forces.
It is true that the BBC didn’t report it but it didn’t report the thousands killed by US drones in
Afghanistan and Pakistan either. Presumably if the BBC doesn’t report something
it hasn’t happened?
attack on civilians in Kiev by fascist gangs
iv.Atkins informed us that the ‘search
(for Nazis) will continue to be in vain.’ Perhaps he missed what happened
in the Greek Parliament when the ‘Jewish’ Zelensky introduced an Azov member.
According to the Greek City Times
By
bringing Nazis into the video call in front of the Greek parliament to speak on
behalf of his government... he insulted the parliaments and the peoples of our
countries.... Zelensky handed a gift to Vladimir Putin by playing the role of
one of his “useful idiots”, lending credence to the Russian president’s claim
to need to “denazify” Ukraine. The Ukrainian president, in his address to the
Greek Parliament, provided a platform to two neo-Nazis who supposedly represent
the resistance of the Ukrainian people and indeed of the Greek homogeneity,
thus undermining his country’s noble battle against Russia’s invasion.
Zelensky was presumably unaware of the fight of Greek people against the Nazi Golden Dawn Party which was responsible for a wave of murders, attacks against the Roma, attacks on migrants, illegal possession of weapons and racketeering..
What is
remarkable is the BBC’s hypocrisy. You have gone to town over Russia’s
occupation of Ukraine but can’t even bring themselves yourself to use the word Occupation when it
comes to Israel’s 55 year occupation of the Palestinian territories. When the BBC reports from Palestine you take care to ensure that the Israeli version of events
is given primacy.
When
Israel assassinated Shireen Abu Akleh, the media investigated
Israel’s assassination of a well known journalist. CBS,
the Washington Post, CNN and even the New York Times. The BBC behaved as it always does.
It faithfully reported the Israeli lie that it was a
firefight in which it was the Palestinians who killed her.
‘Abu Aqla was shot dead in disputed circumstances on
Wednesday, with Israel and Palestinians trading blame’
Such equivalence
is not part of the BBC's coverage when it comes to Ukraine
As David
Roger, a former BAFTA winner wrote in an email to me, the BBC employs a
sophisticated system to weed out anything that might give offence to the
Israeli Embassy.
‘when I worked in-house at the BBC
for a few months I met two journalists who were resigning because they said the
whole news department had been told by the then BBC1 Commissionerto stop showing Israel in any bad light that
would bring the Embassy down on their heads . It was Embassy intervention that
had got Jeremy Bowen brought home after he stood in Gaza in 2014 and angrily
refuted Israeli claims that the hundreds of dead children were being used as
human shields.
They stressed reporters could
file excellent reports giving the true
picture but they were all filtered & in effect redacted by the London
editors . The 24 news channel I feel often escapes the censorship that fillets
the main channel news. Their long live footage of the Shireen funeral attack
was really chilling and there was a half hour interview with her colleague
who’d been trapped beside her that was very powerful .
None of this ever reaches their
main channel bulletins or the truly dreadful Newsnight & Breakfast
programmes . It’s the editors .
The BBC
has consistently portrayed Ukraine as a democratic state despite the fact that the
Communist Party of Ukraine and all left-wing parties and independent media are
banned.
Ukraine’s SBU hunts down anyone who opposes
the war or who supports secession
The
deliberate targeting for assassination and torture by the Internal Security
Police SBU is also ignored by the BBC. For example
An appeal by Mayor of
Kupiansk, Gennady Nikolaevich Matsegora, for the return of his daughter who's
been kidnapped by Ukraine's SBU as a way of getting at him. This has happened
to a number of Mayors who don't follow Zelensky's narrative
Vlodymyr
Struk the Mayor of Kreminna in Luhansk, was abducted from his home and murdered by Ukrainian forces for his support
for a separate Luhansk. Imagine that someone advocating Scottish independence was murdered for their views. This is the reality of Ukraine over the past 8 years.
Denis Kireev was executed by the SBU
Denis
Kireev, a negotiator for Ukraine was considered by the SBU to be too interested
in reaching a peace agreement. The SBU therefore abducted and executed him. Or Mikhail & Aleksander
Kononovich who have been arrested because they are communists.
Dmitri Djangirov is another journalist branded
pro-Russian who has gone missing. Between 1991 and 2018 some 65 journalists
have been murdered in Ukraine. Yet unlike Russia, Ukraine’s
murder of journalists goes unreported by the BBC. Why?
Ukraine's war crimes are not something that
the BBC is prepared to show - all war crimes are committed by Russia
There is no
doubt that the Russian Army has committed war crimes and the BBC have faithfully reported these. But it has comprehensively ignored war crimes committed by Ukrainian forces. According to the BBC
the Ukraine Army are an adult version of the Boy Scouts.
Bucha
At the
beginning of April in Bucha Russian forces were alleged to have massacred over 700
Ukrainians. There is evidence that this was carried out by Ukraine’s National
Police and its Safari Unit. The BBC have, of course, ignored anything contradicting NATO's narrative.
In an article and on my blog I explained that the massacre in
Bucha was probably a false flag atrocity attributed to Russia.
The independent Scheerpost
has an article by Joe Lauria, editor-in-chief of Consortium News
and a former U.N. correspondent for The Wall Street Journal, Boston Globethat
also questions the accepted narrative. Questions
Abound About Bucha Massacre which argues:
‘The West has
made a snap judgment about who is responsible for the massacre at the Ukrainian
town of Bucha with calls for more stringent sanctions on Russia, but the
question of guilt is far from decided.’
Laurie’s article notes that:
Evidence of
crimes in Bucha appeared only on the fourth day (after the Russian withdrawal)
after the Security Service of Ukraine and representatives of Ukrainian media
arrived in the town. All Russian units completely withdrew from Bucha on March
30, and ‘not a single local resident was
injured’ during the time when Bucha was under the control of Russian
troops,” the Russian MOD said in a post
on Telegram.
What
happened then on the 1st and 2nd Jason Michael McCann pointed
out in a piece in Standpoint Zero thatThe
New York Times was in Bucha on Saturday and did not report a massacre.
In Bucha,
the NYT was close to the neo-Nazi Azov Battalion, whose soldiers
appear in the paper’s photographs. In his piece, McCann suggests that Azov may
responsible for the killings:
“Something
very interesting then happens on [Saturday] 2 April, hours before a massacre is
brought to the attention of the national and international media. The US and
EU-funded Gorshenin Institute online [Ukrainian language] site Left Bank announced
that:
‘Special
forces have begun a clearing operation in the city of Bucha in the Kyiv region,
which has been liberated by the Armed Forces of Ukraine. The city is being
cleared from saboteurs and accomplices of Russian forces.’
The
Russian military has by now completely left the city, so this sounds for all
the world like reprisals. The state authorities would be going through the city
searching for ‘saboteurs’ and ‘accomplices of Russian forces.’ Only the day
before [Friday], Ekaterina Ukraintsiva, representing the town council
authority, appeared on an information video on the Bucha Live Telegram page wearing
military fatigues and seated in front of a Ukrainian flag to announce ‘the
cleansing of the city.’ She informed residents that the arrival of the Azov
battalion did not mean that liberation was complete (but it was, the Russians
had fully withdrawn), and that a ‘complete sweep’ had to be performed.”
Not only NATO but the BBC doesn't manage to see any neo-Nazis
Does
this not raise suspicion? Clearly not because the BBC never questions NATO’s narrative. The BBC only reports the official
version of events. It does not investigate. It acts as a conduit for our rulers’
lies and propaganda.Which is why it is
having a hard time today explaining Russia’s victories in the Donbas.
It is a mystery why there were no bodies
evident in Bucha when the Mayor spoke beaming to cameras on March 31. This also
includes a clip of the head of the Safari Police Unit, neo-nazi Korotkykh asking
for permission to shoot civilians - again not something the BBC would show
Why there were no bodies
evident in Bucha when the Mayor spoke beaming to cameras on March 31.
Ros Atkins and the BBC ignore the wave of neo-Nazi attacks on Gypsies
This
is why, alone of daily papers, the Morning Star does not appear on ‘What the Papers Say’. The excuse is that
it’s a paper of the Communist Party. Yet the Telegraph, which is the house
paper of the Tory Party, does appear. Virtually all papers are owned by billionaires
like Rupert Murdoch and Lord Rothermere. That does not bother the BBC because
they all sing from the same hymn sheet. They were, like the BBC, opponents
of Corbyn.
I
trust therefore that you will understand that, being Jewish, I have no
intention to help subsidise a propaganda broadcasting corporation that treats
Ukraine’s neo-Nazis as the new normal.
Yours sincerely,
Tony
Greenstein
The
following links are related to this story but contain information that runs
counter to the BBC narrative on Ukraine.