Zionism ‘Started with the kind of aims with which Hitler started’ Robert Waley Cohen
The first thorough analysis of relevant British and US archives, 16 Dec. 2016
State of Terror: How terrorism created modern Israel.
Thomas Suárez. Bloxham, UK: Skyscraper Publications.
Thomas Suárez. Bloxham, UK: Skyscraper Publications.
By Iain Chalmers
This review is from: State of Terror (Hardcover)
I haven’t read this book but it seems fascinating. I and others have always known about how the Zionist movement sought to block any avenues of escape, other than Palestine, for Jewish refugees during WW2 . The aim was to use the refugees in order to batter open the gates of Palestine for Jewish immigration.
We also know, not least from the agents involved,such as Naim Giladi, that Zionist agents were involved in planting bombs in areas Jews frequented in Iraq and Morocco, among other Arab states, with the aim of simulating anti-Semitism and thereby provoking a stampede of Jews to the Israeli state.
However I didn’t know about the targeting of non-Zionist Jews although nothing about Zionism would at all surprise me.
Today, as Zionism seeks to portray itself as the ‘national liberation movement of Jews’ the kind of movement in whose mouth butter wouldn’t melt, it’s good to be reminded of the sordid racist and bloody record of the Zionist movement.
People interested in knowing how the state of Israel came to be established are indebted to Israeli historians, in particular Tom Segev, Benny Morris, Avi Shlaim and Ilan Pappé. Drawing on archives and other Israeli sources, these researchers have provided us with evidence that standard Zionist narratives about the creation of Israel do not stand up to scrutiny.
It seems surprising that, until now, relevant British Government archives have not received detailed attention. Thomas Suárez has now published a 400-page account of his findings from meticulous research, drawing especially on documents in the British National Archives at Kew, London, and also US Central Intelligence Agency papers. Ilan Pappé describes Suárez’s book - State of Terror - as “the first comprehensive and structured analysis of the violence and terror employed by the Zionist movement and later the state of Israel against the people of Palestine.”
What does State of Terror tell us that we didn’t already know about the violence and terror, within Palestine and beyond, employed by a determined settler-colonialist movement led principally by European, secular Jews?
The book refers to widely known terrorist acts against the British mandate government of Palestine (such as the dynamiting of the King David Hotel), and to terrorist attacks on the indigenous population of Palestine (such as that at Deir Yassin). State of Terror ‘revisits’ these notorious examples of terror directed against targets that stood in the way of establishing an ethno-supremacist settler state intended exclusively for Jews, and self-defined as the state of all Jews, everywhere.
Suárez introduced me to many other examples of Zionist terrorism with which I was not familiar, documented in almost numbing detail, and supported by references to hundreds of archival documents. Anyone who wishes to challenge his analysis has a great deal of work to do.
A feature of the book which has not been covered systematically elsewhere is terrorism and other measures used by the Zionist movement against non-Zionist Jews, within and outside Palestine. Some of these have also previously been well documented, but are less well known than they should be. They reveal the lengths to which the Zionist movement was prepared to go to secure its ambitions to populate Palestine and neighbouring territories with Jews, and ‘cleanse’ these territories of non-Jews.
Zionism - “starting with the kind of aims with which Hitler had started.... seemed to be based on one religion and one race.”, Robert Waley Cohen
In November 1940, under the authority of future prime minister Moshe Sharett, a Hagana bomber blew a hole in the side of the ship Patria to prevent its departure for Displaced Persons to camps in Mauritius. Of the 267 killed, most were Jews fleeing the war in Europe. Cinemas, printing presses, kiosks, radar stations, bridges, trains, roads, and cars were bombed, and the terror did not just target British and Palestinians, but ‘uncooperative’ Jews as well.
Suárez writes: “Both before and after 1948, hundreds of thousands of people in Europe, North Africa, and the Middle East became fair game for Zionist violence because they were Jewish, since Zionism depended not just on the transfer of non-Jewish Palestinians out of Palestine, but also on the transfer of Jews into Palestine. Anti-Jewish tactics included manipulating the Displaced Persons (DC) camps, thwarting safe haven opportunities in other countries [than Palestine], kidnapping Jewish orphans, [persuading Jewish children of non-Zionist Jews to betray their parents], and, [after 1948], destroying Jewish communities in North Africa and the Middle East through propaganda and false-flag ‘Arab’ terrorism – all to ship ‘ethnically correct’ people to Palestine in the service of the settler state”.
At a secret meeting in London in 1941 which involved Weizmann and Ben Gurion, a non-Zionist industrialist, Robert Waley Cohen, observed that the Zionists were “starting with the kind of aims with which Hitler had started”, and which “seemed to be based on one religion and one race.” When, a few years later, Roosevelt developed a plan to resettle half a million persons displaced by fascism in Europe, the initiative was derailed by Zionists intent on denying resettlement of European Jews anywhere other than Palestine.
More than any other book I have read, Thomas Suárez’s State of Terror lays bare the ruthlessness of the Zionist movement in its determination – unbroken since its inception at the end of the 19th century and continuing today - to establish a settler state with no defined borders, populated exclusively by Jews. And the book really brought home to me the ways that Zionism has benefitted from (and continues to thrive on) discrimination against Jews - real, alleged, or actively manufactured.
Politicians and others who acquiesce in or actively support the methods used by Zionism should read this book and consider what lessons it holds, not only for the people of Israel and Palestine as Zionism acts out ethno-religious superiority and messianic fundamentalism, but for all of us, given that Israel is one of the world’s few nuclear-armed states.
16 December 2016
Declaration: I learned of Britain’s key role in creating the Israeli-Palestinian conflict during my first visit to Palestine in 1963. I subsequently worked for two years as a United Nations medical officer in Khan Younis in a clinic then serving over 40,000 refugees. I have returned to Gaza at intervals since then. I am a member of the steering group of the Lancet-Palestinian Health Alliance to promote research to help improve health and health services for Palestinians. I make financial donations to several Israeli and Palestinian human rights organisations and charities.
|1946 train bombing, image from Tom Suarez's book State of Terror|
A review of State of Terror: How terrorism created modern Israel, by Thomas Suárez. Published today in the UK, available for pre-order in the U.S.
To introduce the theme of this book, I can do no better than to quote its endorsement by Prof. Ilan Pappé:
A tour de force, based on diligent archival research that looks boldly at the impact of Zionism on Palestine and its people in the first part of the 20th century. The book is the first comprehensive and structured analysis of the violence and terror employed by the Zionist movement, and later the state of Israel, against the people of Palestine.
Thanks to Prof. Pappé and other Israeli ‘new’ historians working from Israeli government archives, we now have a good understanding of the extent of the catastrophe which befell the Palestinian people in the 1947-49 period as the Zionist forces fought through Palestine either driving out the non-Jewish population, or, if they fled, taking over their property and destroying empty villages.
The less well-known history of the period before this, from the Balfour Declaration of 1917 through the British Mandate of 1922-1948 has now been thoroughly researched in this new book by Thomas Suárez, working largely from British Government archives. He continues the story until the end of the 1956 war in which Israel, Britain and France attacked Egypt.
The book is a substantial work of historical scholarship of over 400 pages, including 680 endnotes, some of them long paragraphs quoting several sources. There is also a very comprehensive index, and a few contemporary photographs. Some maps of the territory would have helped the reader follow the story.
The story he tells is of a Zionist elite determined from the beginning to turn all of Palestine into a Jewish state in which the local non-Jewish Arab population would be either subjugated or expelled. The Zionists were quite willing to use violence and terrorism to achieve this aim, and the book traces the resulting unhappy history in detail, to the extent that, in places, it reads like a catalog of Zionist terror attacks. The Zionist policy is made clear in this quote from Menachem Begin, later a Prime Minister of Israel, which appears at the head of the book’s Introduction:
“We intend to attack, conquer and keep until we have the whole of Palestine and Transjordan in a Greater Jewish State”.
The author does not deny or condone the existence of Palestinian Arab terrorism, but shows how it was then (and remains today) “a reaction to Zionist ethnic subjugation and expropriation of land, resources and labour, with non-violent resistance having proved futile”. Whereas the Palestinian terrorists were loose bands of guerillas operating in the country districts, the Zionist terrorists were organized militias operating from within urban centers under the protection of those communities.
As Palestinian terrorism died down after the brutal suppression of the Arab protests in 1936, Zionist terror escalated, particularly after the 1939 White Paper which placed restrictions on Jewish immigration, “targeting anyone in the way of its political objectives – Palestinian, British or Jewish”. During the second world war, the official Zionist militia, Hagana, toned down its attacks on the British. Both Arab and Jewish Palestinians volunteered to join the Allied forces, though the Jews insisted on their own regiment.
From 1942 onwards, when it was clear that the Allies were going to win the war, the Zionists restarted their campaign of wholesale terrorism (as the British described it) to establish a Zionist state by force: a campaign which eventually forced Britain’s decision to abandon the Mandate, leading to the UN Partition Plan, civil war, ethnic-cleansing of the Arab population, and the unilateral declaration of the State of Israel in 1948.
|Tom Suárez in the West Bank. Photo credit Sainatee Suárez|
The book makes the important point that in the early days most of world Jewry were opposed to Zionism. In Britain, the Jewish cabinet minister Lord Montagu, supported by other Jewish leaders, viewed the Zionists as collaborators with the anti-semites who were delighted with the idea of the Jews expelling themselves from their current homelands. Montagu was instrumental in changing the aim of the Balfour Declaration from “Palestine AS THE Jewish national home” to the vaguer “A Jewish national home IN Palestine”. Orthodox Jews, including the indigenous Arab Jews of Palestine, thought that the return of the Jews to the Land of Israel could not take place until the time of the Messiah, and rejected Zionism as an attempt to replace Jewish religion with a secular, nationalistic ideology. Liberal Jews did not believe that Jews constituted a national group who needed a political home, and were loyal to their existing homeland. In the USA a group of (mainly Reform) rabbis established the anti-Zionist American Council for Judaism, still active today.
The book also reveals the Zionist willingness to use violence against their Jewish opponents; their conviction that all Jews had an obligation to leave their homelands to go to Palestine; their willingness to stir up anti-semitism to encourage such migration; and their attempts to prevent displaced Jews going anywhere other than Palestine.
|Jerusalem from the north, during the Mandate period, an image from Tom Suarez's book State of Terror|
The coverage of historical events in the book is somewhat sketchy, and might confuse the general reader not already familiar with the topic: for example, the 1917 Balfour Declaration is discussed but the text is not provided. It presents the 1947 UN Partition Plan simply as a division of Palestine (excluding Jerusalem) into two states, Jewish and Arab, as if they were to be independent sovereign states. In fact, they were to be joined in a confederation effectively under UN trusteeship, and created by a process in which there was no place for a unilateral declaration of independence. Ben-Gurion’s attempt in Israel’s Declaration of Establishment to justify it through the Partition Plan was a fraud. We are told that the Declaration did not acknowledge any borders for the new state, but not told that the Zionists were forced to make a formal declaration of borders as proposed by the Partition Plan in order to achieve recognition by the USA. This is significant because it makes it clear that Israel was not invaded by 5 Arab armies on 15 May 1948, as Zionists claim: most of the fighting in the subsequent war was outside its borders, and only Syrian and Egyptian troops entered Israeli territory.
This book is true, and it is important. It proves beyond doubt that Israel is not the perpetual victim of Arab violence that it claims to be, but has been the aggressor throughout the history of the conflict.
Thomas Suárez is to be congratulated and thanked for his work. This book is a tremendous achievement by a writer who is also a talented musician and an expert in historic cartography.
UK Edition published by Skyscraper Publications, 13 October 2016, RRP £20.
Format: Hardcover, 417 pages
Available on amazon.co.uk
US Edition published by Interlink-Olive Branch, November 23, 2016, $20
Format: Paperback, 288 pages
Available for pre-order on amazon.com.
Electronic edition forthcoming. The book has its own website at state-of-terror.net