You are Simply Wrong
to Say That
the Genocide in Gaza ‘is wholly Jewish in
its implementation’.
Susan Abulhawa | This House Believes Israel is an Apartheid State
Responsible for Genocide
Susan
Abulhawa is a Palestinian-American writer, novelist, poet and activist, best known for her bestselling
novel Mornings in Jenin and for founding the children's organization
Playgrounds for Palestine.
On
November 29, 2024, Abulhawa was invited by the Oxford Union to debate the
motion "This House Believes Israel is an Apartheid State Responsible for
Genocide". She spoke in favour of the motion which was carried with a
majority of 278 to 59. The Oxford Union later deleted her original recording on
YouTube and uploaded a censored version. The parts of Abulhawa's speech that
were edited out by the Oxford Union included her mentions of the IDF's abuse of
Palestinian and Lebanese civilians and the IDF's use of "booby trapped
toys"
Abulhawa
recently posted an article on her substack
expressing her outrage at the continued genocide in Gaza and Jewish support for
the genocide.It is an outrage we all
feel.
The International
Court of Justice has found just found Myanmar guilty
of perpetrating a genocide against the Rohinga. It was an application that
Britain supported
when it intervened in the case brought by Gambia. Over 10,000 people
were massacred. The same British government, first under the ‘Zionist without qualification’ Keir
Starmer and now Andy Burnham, says that it cannot express an opinion on whether
Israel is guilty of genocide when over 75,000 Palestinians (at the very
minimum) have been murdered.
I decided
to write an open letter to Susan Abulhawa because, although understandable, her
statement that ‘material Zionism (i.e.
the Genocide) ... is wholly Jewish in its
implementation’ . is, I believe profoundly mistaken.
Tony
Greenstein
Dear
Susan,
I want to
say a few things before I explain why your article on
substack is wrong, dangerously wrong.
Firstly I
have the greatest admiration for your passion and integrity, which we witnessed
two years ago in the debate
at Oxford Union. Your speech was a magnificent tour de force with passion and articulacy going hand in hand.
Secondly
I admire your refusal to let the racist censors and hypocrites of the Oxford
Union, who are happy to invite fascists like Tommy Robinson to speak in the
name of ‘freedom of speech’ triumph. The Oxford Union was willing to excise
from the record those parts of your speech which the Zionists and supporters of
genocide objected to. The Oxford
Union retreated and agreed
a settlement on your terms.
Thirdly I
understand the pain that you and Palestinians feel about the fact that many Jews
in the West have either supported the genocide or remained silent whilst their
‘leaders’ supported the starvation, the rapes, the mass murder and all the
other atrocities.
I share
in your pain, not least because Jews above all should be the first to condemn Israel’s
genocide given their own experiences. However Zionism, the political and ideological
heir to Hitler and the Nazis, has no such qualms.
Not only
am I pained but I’m also angry that those who claim to represent the memory of
the Jews who died at the hands of the Nazis, use that memory in order to
justify Israel’s genocide and extermination. In so doing they defile the memory
of those they claim to respect.
"A VICTORY FOR FREE SPEECH": Tony Greenstein speaks
following his acquittal at Kingston Crown Court
As I said
in my speech
to Kingston Crown Court last August,
What I have always fought against was those who used
the murder of 6 million Jews in order to justify the murder and genocide of
others.
However I
can’t agree with your comments about
the debate about Zionism being irrelevant or your belief that the genocide ‘is wholly Jewish in its implementation’.
This is simply not true. What you are doing is letting off the hook those who
are responsible for funding and arming Israel.
The
United States does not supply billions of dollars of arms to Israel and Andy
Burnham does not allow RAF flights overflying Gaza to collect intelligence for
the IDF because they love Jews so much. Friedrich Merz doesn’t supply
30% of the weapons used in the genocide because he is wracked by guilt over
Germany’s role in the holocaust of Jews.
Imperialism
supports the Israeli state because it sees it as in its interests to have a
stable settler-colonial state at the heart of a vital region, economically and
strategically. It was Napoleon who first supported
the idea of a ‘Jewish’ state in Palestine. This was taken up by a raft of
British imperialists from Lord Palmerston to Arthur Balfour and Winston
Churchill. They all saw the advantages of an armed settler state setting Arab
against Arab and bolstering authoritarian Arab states.
I share
your anger at the role of all too many Jews in supporting the genocide in the
name of fighting ‘anti-Semitism’. I detest war criminals like Chief
Rabbi Mirvis who has played the role of genocide
cheer leader. Mirvis’s place is in Nuremberg not the House of Lords. He is
no different from Father Tiso, the priest and President of the Nazi puppet
state Slovakia who was hanged as a collaborator.
Those
Jews who cheerlead the genocide whilst denying it is happening are no better
than neo-Nazi holocaust deniers. It is no wonder that their best friends are
people like Tommy Robinson and Nigel Farage. Zionism today has shed its social
democratic pretensions. It is an openly far-right pastime.
But I
would also caution against the assumption that most Jews outside Israel are
supporters of the genocide. The United States is a very good example. All the
major Jewish organisations are Zionist organisations and fully committed to an
Israel right or wrong stance.
But as
yourself admitted half of the Jewish population in Michigan voted for Abdul
el-Sayed for Sentor. In fact it was between 57%
and 60%.
Even in
Britain, which has a more conservative Jewish population 24% describe
themselves as anti-Zionist or non-Zionist. But among young Jews (20-29) 24% identify
as anti-Zionist and 20% as non-Zionist.
In the
United States just 37% of Jews identify
as Zionists compared to 66% in Britain. 32% of young Jews (18-34) identify as
anti-Zionist or non-Zionist.
39% of
American Jews say Israel is committing
genocide compared to 51% who don’t. But regardless it is irrelevant how many
Jews support or oppose the genocide. It is not Jews, either in this country or
the United States who are responsible for western support for Israel but the
elites in both countries. Jews are the moral alibi for western imperialism.
As
AlHaig was reputed
to have said, ‘Israel is the largest
American aircraft carrier in the world that cannot be sunk, ... and is located
in a critical region for American national security.’ Or as Joe Biden said, if Israel did not
exist it would have had to be invented.
Expelled Ugandan Asians Arrive at Schipol, Amsterdam
Jews
occupy the same position in relation to US imperialism that groups like South
Asians and Indians occupied in the British colonies in East Africa. These
middlemen minorities often took the brunt of anger of the Africans, resulting
in the Ugandan Asians being expelled
altogether in August 1972.
You say
that ‘The raging debate on the origin of
zionism is academic’ during a genocide and that ‘I don't care if zionism was first a Christian idea.’ Well you
should. This debate is crucial to winning the argument that there is nothing
Jewish about Zionism. That is why Molly Crabapple and Ben Moser’s books are so
important.
We have
to change the terms of debate. Zionism and the imperialists use Jews, ‘anti-Semitism’
and Jewish ‘safety’ as a justification for the genocide, a moral comfort
blanket.
We have
to make it clear that Zionism, far from being a Jewish phenomenon was the
product of Christian anti-Semitism. That Christian Zionism rested on the belief
that Jews did not belong in non-Jewish society. Which is why, during the Nazi
era, the Zionists were only too willing to work with the Nazis.These are not irrelevant questions.
So when
you say that the genocide and ethnic cleansing (‘material Zionism) ‘is wholly Jewish in its implementation’ you
could not be more wrong. Without American and Germanweapons,
British overflights of Gaza supplying intelligence and economic and political
support Israel could not have carried out the genocide. Starmer, Biden, Merz
and Trump are every bit as much war criminals as Netanyahu and Gallant.
You talk
of how all the
"holocaust
museums"... have either been silent on this first live-streamed genocide
in human history, or they've closed ranks with other mainstream Jewish
institutions, all of them running cover and giving support to Israel,
This is very
true. It was why I wrote Zionism
During the Holocaustwhose subtitle is the ‘weaponisation of memory in the service of State and Nation.’ The
Holocaust has been used as a propaganda weapon to cloak western imperialism and
its Israeli guard dog in the mantle of the holocaust dead.
Why do
you think that the US Holocaust Museum exists in Washington, lavishly funded by
the American tax payer, yet there is no equivalent museum to slavery or the extermination
of the Native Americans? The numbers of slaves and indigenous Americans who
were slaughtered is far greater than 6 million yet there is no inclination to
remember them because there are no strategic or political imperatives to do so.
The
behaviour of all these institutions is shameful. For Zionists ‘never again’
means never again for Jews not for everyone. When
the Los Angeles Holocaust Museum posted a graphic on Instagram
with the message ‘Never again can’t only
mean never again for Jews’, there was an immediate backlash from the Zionists.
Their complaint was that the statement might be interpreted as referring to
Israel’s genocide in Gaza, resulted in the post being deleted. The museum issued a new statement:
We recently posted an item on social media that was part of a
pre-planned campaign intended to promote inclusivity and community that was
easily open to misinterpretation by some to be a political statement reflecting
the ongoing situation in the Middle East. That was not our intent.
Karen
Pollock of the Holocaust Education Trust
went even further. She condemned the ‘shameful’ comparisons between the holocaust in Gaza and
the Nazi genocide.
We should
take on board what Primo Levi and his interviewer concluded in an interview in
1982 after the massacre of Palestinians in the Sabra and Chatilla refugee
camps.
Joan
Acocella recalled
how Primo Levi, the famous Italian Jewish survivor of Auschwitz, told a
reporter, Filippo Gentiloni, from the Italian newspaper Il Manifesto,
that
“Everybody is somebody’s Jew,”.... At that point in the
interview, printed on June 29, 1982, Gentiloni closed the Levi quote and added
a sentence of his own: “And today Palestinians are the Jews of the
Israelis.”
You say
that you want to talk about the dangers that Jewish supremacy poses to
humanity, and to Palestinians in particular. This is dangerous talk. Not
because it endangers Jews because it endangers Palestinians by poisoning and
polluting their narrative.
If what
you mean is the Jewish Supremacism that we see in Israel then that is simply a
description of the racism that always accompanies settler colonialism. White
Supremacism was a feature of South Africa Apartheid and the Jim Crow Deep
South. Colonialism and in particular its settler colonial variant is always,
without exception, racially supremacist. Jewish Supremacism is a function of
Zionism, which you think we should not talk about.
But if
what you mean Jewish Supremacism outside Israel then you are in danger of
playing into the hands of the far-right conspiracy theorists. It is absurd to
talk of Jewish Supremacy in the United States where Jews form less than 2.5% of
the population. In Britain Jews form about 0.5%. Jews are singled out by our
rulers for ‘protection’ against anti-Semitism precisely because the mainly non-Jewish
ruling class wants to associate Jews with British support for the Israeli
state.Imperialism always wants a moral
rationale for its actions.
Bruce Springsteen - Streets Of Minneapolis (Official
Audio)
But I
also want to take this opportunity to raise the real political problem of this
genocide. It is a question that is rarely discussed. It is the family secret
that is kept under lock and key. You say that
Besides the apathy of the Arab masses and complicity of Arab
governments, nothing in this genocide has surprised me more than the widespread
support Israel continues to enjoy among western Jews
I have
already made clear my own disgust at the support of western Jews for the genocide.
After all it was nine of these misfits who reported me to the police for my
alleged support for Hamas. But even if the majority of western Jews had opposed
the genocide from day one then that would have made no difference to the West’s
support for the genocide.
But if
the Arab masses had risen up against their own rulers, their collaboration and
complicity with Israel, then I have no doubt that Israel would have been halted
in its tracks.
We have
seen how the Houthis and Iran, because of the wars forced upon them, have
forced the United States to pull in its horns.It is the failure of the Arab revolution that allows Israel to get away
with its genocide.
The interdiction
by Ansarallah (Houthis) of Israeli ships and its closing of Eilat, was the only
contribution that the Arab world has made to the fight against Israel. Today the
ruler of Syria, Abu Mohammad al-Jolani, of Al Qaeda’s franchise in Syria, HTS, is
in league with Israel and the United States.
The
Palestinian leadership and the PLO bear a great deal of responsibility for
having agreed to the Oslo
Accords which disarmed the Palestinians and turned them into their own
policemen. The Palestinian Authority has become Israel’s military
sub-contractor.
The PLO,
even before Oslo, had no ambition other than to become another repressive Arab
regime. Whereas most liberation movements, at least until they achieve power,
have a radical social programme which could appeal to others outside their
ranks, the major Palestinian organisations had nothing to say about capitalism
and imperialism, still less about the corrupt and repressive Arab regimes.
The PLO
preferred Saudi and Gulf funding of their diplomatic offices throughout the
world to support for revolutionary struggle in those countries. I except groups
like the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine. The mere fact that
Hamas, the Islamic Resistance Movement, could rise to power in Gaza speaks
volumes about the political bankruptcy of the main Palestinian resistance
force, Fateh.
It is
this, not Jewish Supremacy, which has been the major obstacle to Palestinian
liberation. In making their bed with the Arab regimes, the PLO took the road to
Oslo and eventually the Abraham
Accords.
If you single
out Jewish Supremacy and exempt western imperialism you mistake the symptoms
for the disease.
‘From the River to the Sea, Palestine will be Free’
Means Exactly That
An End to Zionism’s Jewish Supremacist
State
UPDATE
Norman has twice ignored, i.e. refused my offer to debate these issues. Clearly he has no confidence in his own positions!
Dear Norman,
You have been one of the most perceptive critics of
Zionist ideology, its misuse of holocaust memory and the practices of the Israeli
state.
So it is with surprise and dismay that during
Israel’s genocidal attack on Gaza, you have suggested that there might be some basis
to Zionist accusations of ‘anti-Semitism’. This is something that Palestine supporters
experience day in day out from the Zionists and the right-wing media. They don’t
expect to hear it from you.
I am referring to your attack on the slogan, ‘From the river to the sea, Palestine will
be free which has become the property of every single Palestinian
demonstration, encampment and protest march.
Norman Finkelstein Speaking to Students at
Columbia University
In your speech to Columbia University students on
April 21you said:
I don’t agree with the slogan
“From the river to the sea, Palestine will be free.” It’s very easy to amend
and just say, “From the river to the sea, Palestinians will be free.” That
simple, little amendment drastically reduces the possibility of your being
manipulatively misunderstood....
any movement has to ask
itself: What is its goal? What is its objective? What is it trying to achieve?
A few years ago, “From the river to the sea” was a slogan of the movement.
However, there’s a very big
difference when you’re essentially a political cult and you can shout any
slogan that you like, because it has no public repercussions or reverberations...
There’s a big difference between that
situation and the situation you’re in today,....
You have to adjust to the
new political reality that there are large numbers of people, probably a
majority, who are potentially receptive to your message. I understand that
sometimes a slogan is one that gives spirit to those who are involved in the
movement. ...
I believe one
has to exercise — not in a conservative sense, but a radical sense — in a
moment like this, maximum responsibility to get out of one’s navel, to crawl
out of one’s ego, and to always keep in mind the question: What are we trying
to accomplish at this particular moment?
Finkelstein speaking to Columbia University Students
It is nothing less than a stab-in-the-back for you
to attack this slogan at a time when it is being criticised
as anti-Semitic by the establishment and racists such as Suella
Braverman. It might be a good idea
if you took your own advice to get out your navel and crawl out of your ego.
At Columbia you shied away from your own argument,
perhaps because you realised that the audience was not receptive to your
argument. But in your Guardian interview you
‘questioned
the slogan “Palestine will be free, from the river to sea” as mostly
ineffective for these purposes, due to how it inflames fears among Israel’s
supporters and gives fuel to arguments that pro-Palestinian protests on US
university campuses are antisemitic and even “genocidal”.
It
was reported
that ‘the students were largely unmoved’.
As soon as you finished speaking they started chanting the very same
slogan! You said:
The two problems I have with that
are very simple. ... If you want to build a mass movement, you want to bring as
many people as possible inside the big tent.... I have no doubt it was those
screaming headlines every day about those student demonstrations that made
Biden realize: “I have to do something now.”
I believe that a political slogan should be as
clear and succinct as possible, to allow for no wiggle room that can be
misinterpreted and exploited by the other side. “From the river to the sea, Palestine will be free” is a slogan that
gives the other side a lot of room to exploit. “What do you mean by Palestine
will be free? Do you mean there is no room for Israel?”
I find this a strange argument. Of course there will
be no room for a Jewish supremacist state. Do you think a free Palestine can co-exist
alongside an apartheid state? Israeli Jews will have the right to continue
living there but on the basis of equality not domination. Just as in South
Africa Whites continued living there after Apartheid fell.
Your problem is that you don’t have an anti-Zionist
perspective. You don’t question why should Israel continue as a Jewish
Supremacist state. Your paradigm is an entirely different one based not on a
set of principles but on what is acceptable to the ‘international community’
and ‘international law’. You justify the resort to imperialism’s legal
architecture on pragmatic not principled grounds.
The ‘rules based order’, ‘international law’ and the
‘international community’ as represented by the UN, serve to legitimise the plunder
and exploitation of western imperialism post-WW2.
Despite your intellectual contributions to the
struggle of the Palestinians you have repeatedly sought to undermine the
solidarity movement by counterposing the justice of its demands to what is
acceptable to imperialism (the ‘international community’).
Only you know your own subjective motivation and why
you feel the need to attack even the most basic demands and campaigns of the
solidarity movement such as Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions [BDS]. You don’t
feel comfortable with anti-Zionism because it questions the very basis of the US
imposed international order.
I
first became aware of your stance when I attended a talk by you arguing for the
two-state solution at the Institute of Education (11.11.2011). I covered it in
a blog,
Norman Finkelstein –A Wasted Opportunity
& Self-Indulgence. I wrote then that
When
Norman Finkelstein says that 2 States represents the best hope for the
Palestinians and that it is now very close, he is living on another planet. The
fact is that Zionism has always opposed any recognition of Palestinian
statehood and for very good reasons. Zionism is a settler-colonial movement. As
such it is expansionist and seeks regional hegemony not confinement,.... There
is absolutely no intention of granting any such thing. At best there will be a
continuation of autonomy under Abbas with the faces of Israeli soldiers and
jailers being replaced by that of Palestinians.
As Moshe Dayan was reported as saying
in Ha’aretz (12.12.75):
Fundamentally,
a Palestinian state is an antithesis of the State of Israel… The basic and
naked truth is that there is no fundamental difference between the relation of
the Arabs of Nablus to Nablus and that of the Arabs of Jaffa to Jaffa… And if
today we set out on this road and say that the Palestinians are entitled to
their own state because they are natives of the same country and have the same
rights, then it will not end with the West Bank. The West Bank together with
the Gaza Strip do not amount to a state… The establishment of such a Palestinian
state would lay a cornerstone to something else… Either the State of Israel —
or a Palestinian state.
The Obama Administration was pushing hard at that
time for Israel to agree to a two-state solution. The Israeli government
refused to countenance it because an Israeli state cannot co-exist alongside
those they have ethnically cleansed in a state, even in a part of Palestine.
The Zionist slogan was ‘a land without a
people for a people without a land’. It wasn’t half or three-quarters of Eretz Yisrael but all of it.
It is your failure to understand the nature and
dynamics of both Zionism and the Israeli state which has led you to campaign
for a two-state solution. What you failed to recognise then and now is that the
two-state solution served but one purpose – as a smokescreen for the continuing
colonisation of the West Bank until such time as a critical mass of settlers
would make such a state impossible to achieve.
Your appeal to the ‘international community’ and
‘international law’ was an appeal to imperialism to be reasonable when
imperialism by definition is unreasonable.
Your advocacy for two states also involved a
catastrophic failure to understand US imperialism in the post-war period.
International law has never provided justice except at the margins. If
international law had prevailed, the American blockade of Cuba would have ended,
Salvador Allende would not have been overthrown and the genocide in Guatemala
would not have occurred.
Today we can see that when international law and the
interests of US imperialism collide, as with the pending arrest warrants for Gallant
and Netanyahu, the US Congress calls for sanctions against them like some
second rate Mafiosi boss.
"I don't feel Israel is a Jewish state, Israel is a lunatic state."
It is because the one democratic state solution means the end of the
Israeli state that you feel the need to attack the slogan Palestine will be free from the river to the sea.’ Despite your
description of Israel as a lunatic or satanic state you refuse to
countenance its decolonisation.
Norman Finkelstein describing BDS as a cult
You have attacked BDS as a ‘cult’ for the same reasons. You argued that
although BDS didn’t demand the eradication of the Israeli state, its three main
demands
i.Israel ends the occupation of the lands
it occupied in 1967.
ii.That it guarantee equal rights and end
discrimination against Israel’s Arab citizens and
iii.That Palestinian refugees had the right
of return.
We
have to be honest,... They [BDS] don't want Israel. They think they're being
very clever, they call it their three tier – we want the end of the occupation,
... the right of return and ... equal rights for Arabs in Israel... they know
the result of implementing all three is what? What's the result? ... There's no
Israel... If you want to eliminate Israel that's your right but I don't think you're
going to reach anybody. I think it's a non-starter.
But what is this Israel that you believe has a right to exist? What is
this Israel that is unable to withdraw from the Occupied Territories, grant
Israel’s Arab citizens equal rights and allow Palestinian refugees the right of
return if not a state of entrenched inequality? Does an apartheid state have
the right to continue in existence?
You also assume that a demand for an end to the Apartheid Israeli state
will not be popular. Certainly it won’t be popular with Western imperialism.
But today, when Israel is engaged in the slaughter of thousands of Palestinian
children, the argument that Israel is a failed genocidal state is more popular
than ever.
In Brighton, from 2012-14 we picketed a Soda Stream shop forcing it to close
down. On innumerable occasions the Zionist counter-demonstrators quoted your
attack on BDS as a ‘cult’ to show that we were extremists. Are you aware of the
damage you are causing?
Controversial
American anti-Zionist academic Norman Finkelstein has launched a blistering
attack on the boycott, divestment and sanctions campaign against Israel,
labelling it a "cult" led by "dishonest gurus".
If BDS was an insignificant cult why did the Israeli
government pass a law
barring its supporters from visiting Israel and another lawallowing Israelis to sue boycott
advocates? Why is it that 38 US states have passed
legislation penalising advocates for
BDS? At the heart of the Empire Israel’s supporters are frightened by BDS.
There
is public consciousness today that there’s something wrong with a state which
privileges Jews. As B’Tselem put
it, there is ‘aregime of Jewish supremacy from the Jordan
River to the Mediterranean Sea: This is apartheid’. The real question is
how we build on what B’Tselem, Amnesty
and HRW
have said.
Your
difficulty, as you explained
in the Guardian is that:
“Palestine will be free” can also mean
something else. It can fit into what’s called the settler colonial framework,
which basically says, “Settlers do not have legitimate rights to the land. The
land belongs to those who are ‘Indigenous’ to it. And everybody else, at most,
can live there on the sufferance of the Indigenous majority, or they have to
pack up and leave.
You
are wrong about what you all the ‘settler colonial framework’. Your solution to
this problem was ‘constructive ambiguity.’
For me, the
ideal slogan would actually be: “From the river to the sea, one person, one
vote, Palestinians will be free.”
Even
if the movement did endorse your clunky slogan do you really think this would
solve the ‘anti-Semitism’ problem? The Zionists would simply respond by saying
that ‘Palestinians will be free’ meant Israeli Jews would not be free. If
anything your proposed slogan falls foul of the very objections that you
yourself make.
The
problem isn’t the wording of a slogan but the determination of imperialism to
protect its racist rottweiler in the Middle East. Your objections are simply a
distraction. You say
that the slogan
‘inflames
fears among Israel’s supporters and gives fuel to arguments that
pro-Palestinian protests on US university campuses are antisemitic and even
“genocidal.’
If
you are correct that the slogan inflames fears among Israel’s supporters then
that is because it demands that they relinquish their privileges. Perhaps I
should remind you of Martin Luther King’s ‘Letter from a Birmingham Jail’
where he wrote:
Lamentably, it is an historical
fact that privileged groups seldom give up their privileges voluntarily.
Individuals may see the moral light and voluntarily give up their unjust posture;
but, as Reinhold Niebuhr has reminded us, groups tend to be more immoral than
individuals.
What
you are trying to do is depoliticise the Palestine solidarity movement for the
sake of bad faith objections. You are allowing the feelings of Zionists and
Israeli students to dictate our slogans.
The
‘anti-Semitism’ that is alleged is the reflex reaction of Israel’s supporters.
When Israel was taken to the ICJ it was ‘anti-Semitism’. When Netanyahu faced a
warrant for his arrest it was ‘anti-Semitism’. Most people can see through
this. We should not pander to it. Our slogans are not for changing!
As
for genocide Israelis, like other settler colonists, see the de-colonisation of
their state and the end to Jewish Supremacy as the destruction of their identity
and therefore genocide.
Ironically,
having begun your talk to Columbia students with a critique of cancel culture
and ‘hurt feelings’, you then engaged in that very same narrative. Israel’s
supporters are ‘hurt’ by the idea of living with Palestinians on the basis of equality.
As
Ali Abunimah argued (Finkelstein, BDS and the destruction
of Israel), Ulster Unionists viewed a united
Ireland as a mortal threat. In 1990 James Molyneaux, leader of the Ulster
Unionist Party, described the Republic of Ireland’s constitutional claim to the
North of Ireland as “equivalent to
Hitler’s claim over Czechoslovakia”.
Abunimah
described
how the language of the Unionists when faced with the possibility of a United
Ireland ‘resembles that used by Zionists.’
For you to describe the abolition of the Israeli state and a one-state
solution, as tantamount to Israel’s “destruction” implies that an end to a Jewish
Supremacist state is equivalent to genocide.
Zionist
objections to the ‘Palestine will be free’
slogan would be no different if you replaced it by ‘Palestinians will be free’ because what they object to is the
disappearance of their Jewish supremacist identity. It appears that this is also
your real objection because at heart you support the idea of a Jewish state.
The
thread running through all your arguments is your belief that Zionism can be
‘normalised’ within the confines of two states. For all your criticism of
Israel’s human rights record and its falsification of history you still believe
that Zionism can return to a ‘golden age’.
This
was brought home to me when we exchanged correspondence in August 2020. You
wrote:
‘I actually don't think Netanyahu is a Zionist. He's
a Jewish supremacist and a ruthless thug. "Zionism" gives people like
him much more credit than they deserve. The original Zionists were austere,
fanatically committed to an Idea. (9.8.2020)
To
which I responded
‘Yes Netanyahu is a Jewish supremacist and a
ruthless thug. But he's also a Zionist. Zionism isn't some benign dream of a future Jewish
utopia.
Professor Norman Finkelstein, whose parents survived the Holocaust, describing Israel as “a satanic state.” pic.twitter.com/4t41jZd7ZB
The Yishuv and Israel's early years had agreeable,
even attractive features: the kibbutzim, the austere life, the idealism. That's
why Chomsky and Deutscher felt such an affinity for it. It was sort of like the
rugged individualism of the settlers in the American West. Something to admire
then, if you weren't an Indian; something to admire in Palestine if you weren't
an Arab. It would be nice if the world came in neat little packages labelled
Good and Evil, but human affairs are more messy. I would have to say, however,
that in my opinion the redemptive features in Israeli life have altogether
vanished, and it's now a pretty Satanic place.
At heart your attempt to
undermine the slogan ‘Palestine will be free’, owes less to any fears of
genocide and more to do with your belief in the mythical past of heroic Labour Zionist
pioneers farming the land that they had just evicted the Palestinian peasants
from.
Chomsky may have enjoyed
his time on a kibbutz, although he also noted that it was built on the
ruins of Arab villages and that ‘some pretty ugly things had happened in
1948’. What Chomsky didn’t understand was that the kibbutzim were stockade
and watchtower settlements marking out the future boundaries of the Jewish
state, Jewish-only settlements founded upon the dispossession of the native population.
It is little wonder that the settlers on the West Bank lay
claim to be the continuation of that pioneering spirit you so admire.
What we need, as Naomi
Klein put it is an ‘Exodus from Zionism’ not a pandering to its unerring ability to
paint itself as the victim, even whilst committing genocide.
Since I suspect that you
won’t be convinced by my arguments I want to challenged you to a debate over these
issues for a wider audience to consider.
Solidarity,
Tony Greenstein
Background to my
letter
Norman Finkelstein
is difficult to pigeon hole. He is not an anti-Zionist nor does he claim to be.
Politically he is close to Noam Chomsky who never disavowed Zionism.
On the other hand Finkelstein’s analysis, dissection and demolition of
various Zionist propagandists and frauds masquerading as
historians and scholars is unsurpassed. ‘Victims’ of his
include Joan Peters, Daniel Goldhagen and Alan Dershowitz.
Finkelstein is without doubt a caustic critic of Zionism and its
pretensions. He is also in the habit of making rash statements that are
damaging to the solidarity movement such as calling BDS a ‘cult’, or advocating
for an apartheid 2-state solution when it is clear to all bar Finkelstein that two
states would, in James
Connolly’s words, create a carnival of reaction on both sides of the border.
Norman Finkelstein on holocaust denier David Irving
I have had some
experience of Finkelstein in a free speech panel discussion when he praised David Irving as a historian without
also mentioning that Irving was a neo-Nazi and holocaust denier whose attempt
to suggest that Hitler knew nothing of the holocaust rested on tampering with and
falsification of his sources.
This led to an article in the Jewish Chronicle and by the CommunitySecurity
Trust which suggested that anti-Zionists had uncritically praised a
holocaust denier. It also led David Rosenberg of the Jewish Socialists Group to
accuse the panel, and David Miller in particular, of agreeing with
Finkelstein’s comments. Rosenberg eventually and grudgingly
withdrew his remarks since I had in
fact corrected Finkelstein.
Finkelstein has continued his tradition of being an iconoclast on the
Palestine question. After the October 7 breakout from Gaza he defended the
uprising as being in the tradition of slave break-outs such as Nat Turner. Yet
more recently he has started attacking the slogan ‘Palestine Must Be Free on grounds not dissimilar to that of the
Zionists.
My Open Letter to Finkelstein expresses my own dismay at his suggestion
that the slogan gives substance to Zionist claims that it could be genocidal.
In so doing he is reinforcing the idea that democracy and equal rights are
somehow genocidal.
From Time Immemorial -Joan Peters Hoax
At the beginning of his career Finkelstein, was the brightest star in
the firmament. His painstaking research in Image and Reality of
the Israel-Palestine Conflictdemolished Joan Peter’s hoax and forgery, From Time Immemorial, (1984). Peters argued that Palestine was an empty land before the
Zionist settlers arrived and that the Palestinians had only migrated to
Palestine as a result of Zionist immigration.
Peters’ argument was similar to that
of White South African settlers who had also argued that South Africa was an
empty land until they arrived. Settler-colonialism has always been attracted to
the idea that the lands they coveted were terra
nullis or empty lands. The natives have always been invisible.
Finkelstein’s review laid the basis for writers like David & Ian
Gilmour to continue the attack on Peters work.They cited errors such as quoting a medieval Arab historian, Makrizi,
who died in 1442, to support her statements about mid-nineteenth century
population movements. (LRB, 7.2.85. ‘Pseudo Travellers’).
The evidence that Peter's thesis was junk came from the Zionists
themselves. Leo Motzkin, a Zionist leader who in 1912 called on the Arabs of
Palestine to transfer themselves to other countries, told delegates to the 2nd
Zionist Congress in 1898 how
‘Completely accurate
statistics about the number of inhabitants do not presently exist. One must
admit that the density of the population does not give the visitor much cause
for cheer. In whole stretches throughout the land one constantly comes across
large Arab villages, and it is an established fact that the most fertile areas
of our country are occupied by Arabs..." (Protocol of the Second Zionist Congress, p.103).
We who
live abroad are accustomed to believe that almost all Eretz Israel is now
uninhabited desert and whoever wishes can buy land there as he pleases. But
this is not true. It is very difficult to find in the land cultivated fields
that are not used for planting.... We who live abroad are accustomed to
believing that the Arabs are all wild desert people who, like donkeys, neither
see nor understand what is happening around them. But this is a grave mistake.
The Arab, like all the Semites, is sharp minded and shrewd. ... The Arabs,
especially the urban elite, see and understand what we are doing and what we
wish to do on the land, but they keep quiet and pretend not to notice anything.
For now, they do not consider our actions as presenting a future danger to
them. … But, if the time comes that our people’s life in Eretz Israel will
develop to a point where we are taking their place, either slightly or
significantly, the natives are not going to just step aside so easily.
Peters ignored this and all other evidence that contradicted her thesis.
Peters’ book attracted rave reviews and
endorsements from the US’spolice state ‘intellectuals’,
such as Barbara Tuchman
and Lucy Dawidowicz.The book neatly fitted
into the Zionist agenda because it challenged the very existence of the
Palestinian refugee problem. The expulsion of the Palestinians in 1948 was according
to them a myth. They had never lived there!Finkelstein described how
I immediately
brought my findings to the attention of 20 or so publications and to several
individuals who I thought would find my discovery of some interest. Only Noam
Chomsky responded. ... I devoted some two months in the New York Public Library
to systematically going through all Peters’ documentation for her central
demographic thesis. To my utter amazement, I discovered that every single piece
of evidence in support of the central thesis of the book was falsified. Every
single one.
Subsequently I
discovered that extensive passages of the book were plagiarized from some
rather ludicrous right-wing Zionist propaganda tracts.
Despite
this no publication would print Finkelstein’s critique. Commentary turned down his response to Daniel Pipes’ review on the
grounds that the reviewer was not qualified to respond to it, which begged the
question why he had reviewed it in the first place!
Finkelstein’s critique of Daniel Goldhagen’s Hitler's
Willing Executioners: Ordinary Germans and the Holocaust (1996), was
equally clinical in its dissection of Goldhagen’s thesis that the holocaust had
occurred because Germans were uniquely anti-Semitic.
Goldhagen held Nazism to be benign except for the Jews. The problem was
not racial fascism but the Germans themselves who were ‘eliminationist’ anti-Semites.
Racism was apparently a biological inheritance. Finkelstein described it as ‘worthless
as scholarship’. See ‘Daniel
Jonah Goldhagen’s ‘Crazy’ Thesis: A Critique of Hitler’s Willing Executioners’
New Left Review I/224, July-August
1997.
In The
Holocaust IndustryFinkelstein argued
that Zionism had harnessed the holocaust to the needs of Zionism and the
Israeli state. Finkelstein took apart the
Zionists’ use and abuse of holocaust memory to both justify their human rights
crimes and to legitimise the apartheid practices of the Israeli state.
The Holocaust Industrytook aim at the US Zionist
establishment which had built up a veritable industry of holocaust publications,
museums and memorials, all with the aim of providing a moral case for the Israeli
State and its treatment of the Palestinians.
Finkelstein showed how the Jewish Claims Conference had stolen and
defrauded the holocaust victims of the reparations that had been intended for
them, paid for by West Germany.
Finkelstein’s ‘Beyond Chutzpah: On the Misuse of Anti-Semitism and
the Abuse of History’ further established his reputation. The book also
proved that Alan Dershowitz, the Harvard Professor of Law, had plagiarised and
copied material from other sources, for ‘The Case for Israel’. He had
also copied their mistakes!
Included in the book was a detailed refutation of Dershowitz’s main
thesis by reference to numerous human rights sources. Herein lay a clue to
Finkelstein’s approach. To him the Palestine Question was primarily a human
rights not a political issue. These human rights abuses have a political cause.
Finkelstein’s primary weakness has been his failure to situate Israel's behaviour
within the political context of imperialism.
One of the consequences of Finkelstein’s attack on Dershowitz, was that
he was denied tenure at DePaul University. A good example of how, in the
aftermath of the ‘War Against Terror’ academic freedom has been relegated to
the status of a curious artefact in the USA.
I first criticised Finkelstein after attending a talk he gave at the Institute of Education in London (11.11.11).
Finkelstein spent the best part of 2 hours arguing why we should support a 2
State solution.
After a pre-talk interview with
activist Frank Barat surfaced my first reaction was that Finkelstein must be
suffering from a mid to late life crisis. Repeatedly he talked about how he had devoted his life time to the cause and how he was growing
tired and weary. He said:
‘Yes BDS
has had some victories, but the way people have promoted it, on the verge of
victory is sheer nonsense – it’s a cult. I’m tired of it. I went through my
cult stage I was a Maoist. There were 2 competing possibilities – you can be a
Maoist/Leninist and waste 20 years of your life. You can work with Ralph Nader,
lot of bills through Congress. Nice we have seat belts and airbags – that was
Nader. I’m not going to be in a cult again. Gurus in Ramallah giving marching
orders.’
You cannot but detect a feeling that Finkelstein believed he had wasted
his life on a cause that didn’t seem to be bearing any fruit. Finkelstein wanted
instant results. Hence Ralph Nader was his political hero for having obtained legislation
in support of seatbelts. An important issue no doubt, but it was hardly an
earth shattering, life-changing event for the world.
Finkelstein argued that ‘If you are serious about politics you can’t
go beyond what the public accepts, and that is international law.’ Herein lay
his most important mistake. He seems to believe that US foreign policy is
subject to popular support. But this isn’t true as Israel’s current genocide
proves.
Not only in Britain
and Germany,
but even in the United
States the public supports an immediate ceasefire. The public has been
extremely critical of Israeli genocide yet Biden, Sunak and Scholtz act in
complete disregard of public opinion.
It is true that Palestine solidarity supporters demand that Israel
upholds international law. But that does not mean we have any illusions in international
law. The fact that the rulings of the ICJ and ICC have been ignored proves
that.
Indeed the US’s reaction to the decision of the ICJ that Israel was
committing a ‘plausible’ genocide was to freeze contributions to UNWRA. Thus
the United States, Britain and other Western countries became complicit in Israel’s
use of starvation as a weapon of war.
The right of an occupied people to resist their occupier is not subject
to the dictates of international law. It is an inalienable right which is why
the decision of the ICC prosecutor, Karim Khan, to issue warrants for Hamas
leaders is so ludicrous. It is as if the leaders of the French and Polish Resistance
should have appeared alongside Goering and the Nazi leaders at Nuremberg.
Congress has passed a resolution imposing sanctions on the ICC and Israel
has stalked
and threatened its previous Chief Prosecutor, Fatou
Bensouda. When the imperialists don’t like the rulings of a
court they threaten the court itself!
Israel does not rule over 5 million Palestinian Arabs because
‘international law’ granted them permission to do so. As the Anti Defamation
League acknowledged the Zionist settlers were intent on “creating
facts on the ground immigration, agricultural settlement of the land’. From
this there came the law, not the other way around.
International law has always been a fiction since it has no independent enforcement
mechanism. Who is going to take the United States to the International Court
for its invasions of Iraq and Afghanistan? What prevented the ICC from issuing
a warrant for the arrest of Bush and Blair like it did for Putin when Russia
invaded Ukraine?
The UN can only act when the United States allows it to. When Israel
breaks international law the US can be relied on to veto any critical resolutions
at the Security Council. To therefore rely, as Finkelstein does, on the
‘international community’ is to fail to recognise the reality of existingpower relations and who calls the shots.