The TUC Decision to Support NATO’s Proxy War in the Ukraine is Shameful but Not Surprising Given Its Record of Subservience to the British State
It is no surprise that Gary Smith of the institutionally
sexist and racist GMB and an avid Zionist, has backed NATO's neo-Nazi allies in Ukraine. The fact that Zelensky has approved laws stripping workers of their rights and banning
left-wing parties, including Platform for Life, which has 44 seats in the 450-seat Ukrainian
parliament, has been no deterrent to
Smith, since he also does his best to suppress workers’ struggles.
What is more remarkable is that Sharon Graham,
who has a reputation for supporting strikes but declared herself ‘non political’
when she was elected General Secretary, has also got into bed with the Zionists. In particular taking
advice from the Campaign Against Anti-Semitism, an
organisation set up and funded by the Israeli state and the Jewish National
Fund,
about banning Jeremy Corbyn – The Big Lie. Graham also has given her support to NATO’s proxy war in Ukraine.
One can only hope that the Socialist
Workers Party and the Socialist
Party, who have both up till now supported Graham, see the error of their
ways and reconsider their support for this British chauvinist.
The TUC motion, which was opposed
by only two unions – the FBU and Bakers Union with the RMT and NEU
abstaining – called for more weapons to be supplied to Ukraine. These
reactionary union bureaucrats, fools all, should bear in mind that a large
percentage of the arms already supplied have found their way onto the private market.
Ukraine
is Europe’s most corrupt state.
Azov Demonstration 2014
The
United States and Britain have been directly
supplying neo-Nazi forces in
Ukraine since 2014, despite a Congressional motion cutting
aid to Azov in 2018. We face the prospect of a new Libya in Europe with
private militias and an ongoing civil war.
There
have already been credible
threats that if Ukraine doesn’t receive enough weaponry then they
will resort to terrorism in Europe. What does NATO think is going to happen
when the war ends? Do they think the fascists will disarm? We could see an
outbreak of terrorism in Europe which will make ISIS seem like a tea party.
flag of the Ukrainian NPGU mining union courtesy of Skwawkbox
Azov symbol bears remarkable similarity to that of the NPGU mining union
The sonnenrad or sunwheel is one of a number of ancient European symbols appropriated by the Nazis. It bears a remarkable similarity to that of the NPGU mining union which was on display at the TUC Congress
Mark
Serwotka of PCS, who has previously been considered on the left, joined
the warmongers in offering “unequivocal
support for those currently suffering occupation by a brutal Russian invasion”.
Serwotka said
that ‘We are with the Ukrainian people
and for Russia out, only the people of Ukraine should decide what the outcome
looks like.” For Serwotka the
activities of open neo-Nazis and the attacks on Russian speaking Ukrainians since
2014 count for nothing.
Paul Massaro is a senior US governmentpolicy advisor for counter-corruption and sanctions
Victoria
Nuland, Assistant Secretary of State in the Biden administration admitted
that the US had funded,
to the tune of over $5 billion, the overthrow of the elected President Yanukovych
in 2014. Fascists were heavily armed when they outgunned the police.
“Our solidarity must know no
borders,” said GMB
President Barbara Plant. Not a word that the GMB is used to using when it comes
to workers nearer home. Unite backed the motion despite its Executive having issued
a statement saying that “wars are
never in the interest of working people”. One wonders whether Sharon Graham
even realises that opposing war and supplying more weapons to Ukraine is a
contradiction.
The GMB has
never extended solidarity to anyone
outside Britain. It has consistently supported Israel’s ethnic cleansing and has
repeatedly sided
with the Jewish Labour Movement, the British wing of Israel’s racist Israeli
Labor Party. At the moment it is trying
to expel a former International Officer
Bert Schounberg for
moving a motion at his branch calling for the disaffiliation of the JLM.
Last year
a GMB resolution supported by Unite under its war mongering General Secretary,
Sharon Graham, called
for increased arms spending. Unbelievably it called on the TUC to back an
increase in arms spending to 3 per cent of GDP. This at a time when the NHS and
schools are being starved of money. As Chris Nineham of Stop the War Coalition wrote
‘It actually
put the TUC to the right of the Tory government which even now only dares to
push for 2.5 per cent arms spending.
John McDonnell has thrown in his lot with Ukraine's neo-Nazi infested armed forces
Andrew
Murray wrote
Last year GMB general
secretary Gary Smith persuaded
the TUC Congress to vote, shamefully if narrowly, to campaign for increased military spending.
At a time of austerity and a
cost-of-living crisis, that decision prioritised the arms industry over the
vital interests of millions of working people, not least the tens of thousands
of GMB members in the beleaguered public services.
It also
revealed that Smith believes that the British government can be trusted with
more weapons, despite overwhelming evidence that they are used either for wars
of aggression or for sale to despotic regimes.
Given Smith’s support for Apartheid Israel, it is no surprise that
this appalling reactionary should demand that the Tories divert yet more money
from the NHS and their own workers in the health service to feed America’s war
industry. It is a shameful comment on the British trade union movement that
this motion was passed.
The
neo-Nazi credentials of the Azov battalion, which has been integrated into the
army and now promoted to brigade status, is well documented.
That did not stop Arsen Avakov, Ukraine’s Interior Minister, a man personally
responsible for integrating far-right groups into the state from defending
them to the online newspaper Ukrayinska Pravda in 2019.
“The shameful
information campaign about the alleged spread of Nazi ideology (among Azov
members) is a deliberate attempt to discredit the ‘Azov’ unit and the National
Guard of Ukraine,”
As even NBC had to admit
even though
Putin is engaging in propaganda, it’s also true that Ukraine has a genuine Nazi
problem… important as it is to defend the yellow-and-blue flag against the
Kremlin’s brutal aggression, it would be a dangerous oversight to deny
Ukraine’s antisemitic history and collaboration with Hitler’s Nazis, as well as
the latter-day embrace of neo-Nazi factions in some quarters.
NBC went on to remind
us that
On the eve of
World War II, Ukraine was home to one the largest Jewish communities in Europe, with estimates as
high as 2.7 million, a remarkable number considering the territory’s
long record of antisemitism and pogroms. By the end, more than half would perish. When
German troops took control of Kyiv in 1941, they were welcomed by “Heil
Hitler” banners. Soon after, nearly 34,000 Jews — along with Roma and other
“undesirables” — were rounded up and marched to fields outside the city on the
pretext of resettlement only to be massacred in what became known as the
“Holocaust by bullets.”
The Babyn Yar ravine continued to fill up as a mass grave for
two years. With as many as 100,000
murdered there, it became one of the largest single killing sites of the
Holocaust outside of Auschwitz and other death camps. Researchers have noted
the key role locals played in fulfilling Nazi kill orders at the site.
Those locals were led
by Stepan Bandera’s Organisation of Ukrainian Nationalists (OUN) and its armed
wing the Ukrainian Insurgent Army (UPA). Ukraine is the only country in the
world to have a national holiday in memory of a Nazi collaborator, Stepan
Bandera. The Times of Israel described how Hundreds
of Ukrainian nationalists march in honor of Nazi collaborator.
Today the British
press plays down the threat of the neo-Nazis in Ukraine. However at the time of
the Maiden coup in 2014 they were singing a different song. The Guardian described
how Azov fighters were both Ukraine's greatest weapon
and its greatest threat.
They quoted Dimitary,
a member of the Azov group as saying that
"I have
nothing against Russian nationalists, or a great Russia, but Putin's not
even a Russian. Putin's a Jew."
You might think that
Zionist groups like America’s Anti-Defamation
League would be prominent in denouncing these neo-Nazis and anti-Semites.
After all they are usually able to spot ‘anti-Semites’ before they have time to unfurl the Palestinian flaga. But strangely enough they have kept remarkable quiet. Even
worse they have been excusing and justifying them.
In 2019 – before it became
politically necessary to whitewash them – the ADL itself warned
that an “extremist group called the Azov
Battalion has ties to neo-Nazis and white supremacists” and issued a report
on how the Ukrainian militia was trying to “connect
with like-minded extremists from the US.”
This Ukrainian extremist group, called The Azov Battalion, has ties to neo-Nazis and white supremacists. Our latest report on international white supremacy details how they try to connect with like-minded extremists from the US: https://t.co/GtvssxwzbN https://t.co/gGHMM8L46k
— ADL (@ADL) September 23, 2019
Ali Abunimah described
how the ADL has been turning a blind eye to Hitler’s accomplices in Ukraine and
even justifying their record. As Abunimah observed ‘So when
Washington goes to war, the lobby will often lend its propaganda services to
the cause.’
This
shows that the Zionist lobby, of which the ADL is the most prominent, are first and foremost supporters of US imperialism.
So now it is rehabilitating the Ukrainian collaborators who helped Hitler
exterminate Jews and Poles.
This
Holocaust revisionism is motivated by the need to whitewash the present-day,
far-right Ukrainian nationalists and neo-Nazis.
The
reason the US, NATO and the European Union gives for sending weapons and
mercenaries to Ukraine is that they are helping a fellow democracy defend its
independence and sovereignty against an illegal invasion by an expansionist,
megalomaniacal madman.
Anrdrii Melnyk is currently Ukraine's Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs
At the outset of my visit to Munich met with UKR community & laid down flowers on the tomb of our hero Stepan Bandera
— Andrii Melnyk (@MelnykAndrij) April 27, 2015
It is
therefore very awkward from a Western perspective that the Ukrainian regime is
underpinned by hard-right fascists and neo-Nazis.
Acknowledging
this fact, Western war propagandists fear, would legitimize Putin’s
claim that the Russian invasion – which has been overwhelmingly
condemned by the UN General Assembly – is justified by a need to
“de-Nazify” and demilitarize Ukraine.
The
dilemma is summed up in an NBC News headline: “Ukraine’s
Nazi problem is real, even if Putin’s ‘denazification’ claim isn’t.”
But most
Western media will no longer even go as far as NBC News in acknowledging this
reality.
The current war can be
traced
directly to the 2014 coup in Ukraine, during which the US and its allies supported
far-right and neo-Nazi elements. The goal was to install a US-friendly regime
that would bring Ukraine into NATO. Moscow has long seen NATO expansion as an
existential threat.
Key
actors in the US-supported coup were neo-Nazi groups like Right Sector, the Azov
Battalion and C14.
They are part of a broader Ukrainian nationalist movement that venerates Bandera,
the leader of the OUN, which collaborated with Hitler during World War II.
In an interview
with Andrew Srulevitch, ADL Director of European Affairs, Professor David
Fishman exonerated the
UPA and Bandera, who were responsible for the slaughter of 300,000
Jews and Poles. Asked about torchlit marches in Kyiv with red and black flags, Fishman had this to
say:
“For Ukrainian
nationalists, UPA and Bandera are symbols of the Ukrainian fight for Ukrainian
independence. The UPA allied with Nazi Germany against the Soviet Union for
tactical – not ideological – reasons.... When Ukrainian nationalists and Jews
look at those red and black flags, we see two different things.’
In fact UPA attacks on
Jews were so ferocious that Jews sought
the protection of the Germans.
The Banderite
bands and the local nationalists raided every night, decimating the Jews
a survivor testified
in 1948.
Jews
sheltered in the camps where Germans were stationed, fearing an attack by
Banderites. Some German soldiers were brought to protect the camps and thereby
also the Jews.
ADL,
which purports to oppose anti-Semitism, carried the interview with Fishman on
its website and in its newsletter. Zionist organisations, which are usually so
concerned about ‘anti-Semitism’, simply echoed NATO
propaganda. As Abunimah observed:
Fishman’s
excuse that Bandera and other Nazi collaborators are “symbols” of the “fight
for Ukrainian independence” mirrors the claims
from American white supremacists that their display of the Confederate battle
flag is merely to honor their “heritage” and not to celebrate a regime that
went to war to protect its “right” to enslave people from Africa.
Dozens of Ukrainian streets
are named after Bandera and in a particularly nice touch Bandera’s street runs
right up to the site of Babi Yar.
Daniel
Lazare, in a review of Grzegorz Rossoliński-Liebe’s Stepan Bandera: The
Life and Afterlife of a Ukrainian Nationalist wrote:
Although
Bandera and his followers would later try to paint the alliance with the Third
Reich as no more than “tactical,” an attempt to pit one totalitarian state
against another, it was in fact deep-rooted and ideological. Bandera envisioned
the Ukraine as a classic one-party state with himself in the role of führer, or
providnyk, and expected that a new Ukraine would take its place under
the Nazi umbrella, much as Jozef Tiso’s new fascist regime had in Slovakia or
Ante Pavelić’s in Croatia.
What we
are seeing is a cynical attempt to rewrite history in order to portray Bandera
and the OUN/UPA as mere Ukrainian nationalists. Why? Because NATO’s Ukrainian
friends identify with Bandera’s alliance with Nazi Germany. Bandera saw
things differently explaining that Ukrainian nationalism had taken shape “in a spirit similar to the National
Socialist ideas”.
That the
BBC and the yellow press is engaged in trying to prettify the Azov Battalion and
assorted neo-Nazis is one thing (see Ros Atkin’s apologia What untruths is Russia
spreading about Nazis in Ukraine?) but for a Zionist organisation which
purports to oppose anti-Semitism to do the same is something else.
As Jimmy Dore observed, there are now
good Nazis as well as bad Nazis. The good ones are pro-Western and publicly, at
least, play down their anti-Semitism.
An example of Azov’s
handiwork was the body of a woman found in the basement of Azov’s HQ in
Mariupol. She had been tortured and a swastika was scratched into her chest.
For which Western media blamed
Russians.
Oleksiy
Kuzmenko’s Far-Right Group Made Its Home in Ukraine’s Major Western Military
Training Hub [George Washington University, September 2021] makes for
sombre reading. Kuzmenko wrote
that:
... since 2018, the National Army Academy (NAA),
Ukraine’s premier military education institution and a major hub for Western
military assistance to the country, has been home to Centuria, a self-described order of “European
traditionalist” military officers that has the stated goals of reshaping the
country’s military along right-wing ideological lines and defending the
“cultural and ethnic identity” of European peoples against “Brussels’ politicos
and bureaucrats.” The group envisions a future where “European right forces are
consolidated and national traditionalism is established as the disciplining
ideological basis for the European peoples.”
The
group, led by individuals with ties to Ukraine’s ... Azov movement, has attracted multiple
members, including current and former officer cadets of the NAA now serving in
the Armed Forces of Ukraine. Apparent members have appeared in photos giving
Nazi salutes and made seemingly extremist statements online.
The
group has been able to proselytize Ukraine’s future military elite inside the
NAA. Members have also gained access to Western military education and training
Institutions.
The
presence of the far right within the NAA is alarming because that institution
is central to the Armed Forces of Ukraine, Western support for that country,
and Western military presence there. Foreign military instructors routinely
engage with the Academy’s cadets at both the Academy proper and the
International Peacekeeping and Security Center it oversees....
Azov
figures and groups linked to Azov also heaped praise on Centuria and shared its
messages online. In January 2019, for example, Eduard Yurchenko, an ideologue
of the Azov movement, praised the group on Telegram, where he now has more than
1,100 subscribers. “You should know that
this is our legendary future growing,” Yurchenko wrote of Centuria,
emphasizing that the group was holding events within the NAA. ...
Galician
Youth, a group
that is linked to the Azov movement and operates in the Western part of
Ukraine, similarly shared Centuria propaganda on Telegram in 2019.
In
May 2021, the United Jewish Community of Ukraine... accused Galician Youth of
spreading anti-Semitic posters in Lviv. The group denied having any connection
to anti-Semitic posters and stated that it condemned anti-Semitism and
xenophobia. Belying these statements, however, Galician Youth events, patches,
etc., feature white nationalist symbols.
The
evidence is overwhelming that the AFU is being penetrated at all levels by
neo-Nazi groups.
Hope not Hate, which
never lost an opportunity to attack anti-racists like Chris Williamson for
‘anti-Semitism’, went out of its way to downplay genuine anti-Semitism in
Ukraine. HnH withdrew
an award to Joe Solo for having supported Chris, though it ended up with egg on their faces
writing that:
Ukraine's
contemporary Jewish community, while facing antisemitism that all Jewish
populations sadly receive, has, in the post-communist era, become a thriving
community in the country with freedoms and protections written in law.
Denazify #Ukraine? Its President is Jewish, Mr. #Putin. Naked aggression is no justification in 2022. #russianinvasion https://t.co/IAW9HOIpNa
— SimonWiesenthalCntr (@simonwiesenthal) February 24, 2022
Eduard Dolinsky, the leader of Ukraine’s Jewish
community clearly disagreed:
Our
government encourages nationalistic groups. Our government encourages
glorification of Nazi collaborator mass murderers and murderers of Jews.
Literally
there are hundreds of monuments, streets named after killers of Jews. You can’t
imagine in the West... a monument to a policeman who was escorting Jews to Nazi
death camps.... We have anti-Semitic incidents every day – vandalism on
Holocaust mass graves, vandalism on Jewish monuments. ... No one was ever
convicted. They always deny the issue.
Zelensky’s Alliance with Ukraine’s
Neo-Nazis
Western propaganda
uses the fact that Zelenskyy is Jewish
to legitimise Ukraine’s Nazis. This is not strange however. Zelensky is a
rabid Zionist and Zionism historically has always koshered anti-Semitism. It
did so with Nazi Germany.
Less than 3 weeks ago
the Israeli Ambassador to Romania,
together with settler leader Yossi Dagan, met with the leader of the
far-right Alliance for the Unity of Romanians party. This is a party that
openly denies the holocaust and is descended from the Iron Guard who in 1941
staged a pogrom in Bucharest and hung the bodies of Jews from meat hooks in
butcher shops. As Ha’aretz observed in its editorial ‘Shared
Values’: Netanyahu’s Israel Cements Another Grim Alliance With Europe’s Far
Right’
Zelensky
is a puppet of Ukraine’s fascists who came to power thanks to patronage from
Ukrainian oligarch, Ihor Kolomoisky. Kolomoisky funded Zelensky’s election campaign whilst also funding
the Azov Battalion and other far-right militias.
In 2019 Zelensky met
with a range of fascist groups telling reporters “I met
with veterans yesterday. Everyone was there – the National Corps, Azov, and
everyone else.” A few seats away from Zelensky was Yehven Karas, leader of
the neo-Nazi C14 gang.
In
April 2021 Zelensky tried to appoint the neo-Nazi former head of the Right
Sector in Odessa, Serhiy Sternenko as head of Ukraine’s Security Service (SBU).
As the former head of the neo-Nazi Right Sector in Odessa, Sternenko was
directly implicated in the 2014 Trade Unions House massacre in Odessa, when 46
trade unionists were burnt alive or shot whilst attempting to flee the burning
building. It is a massacre that Smith and Graham are remarkably unconcerned or ignorant about.
In
November 2021 Dmytro Yarosh, announced that he had been appointed as an
advisor to the Commander-in-Chief of the AFU. Yarosh led the Right Sector from
2013-2015, vowing to lead the “de-Russification” of Ukraine.
A month
later, as war with Russia drew closer, Zelensky awarded Right Sector commander Dmytro Kotsyubaylo
the “Hero of Ukraine” commendation. Kosyubaylo keeps a pet wolf in his
frontline base, and likes to joke to visiting reporters that his fighters “feed it the bones of Russian-speaking
children.”
Aren't there some prominent AWL members in RMT ? If so, could that impact the unions views on things like Ukraine ?
ReplyDeleteTony: Keep on reflecting the light!
ReplyDeleteTony, what a mish-mash of a blog, not one of your best. You have thrown the kitchen sink at attempting to conflate anti Zionism with some sort of justification for Putin's actions. Ever since I've been old enough to vote, more than fifty years ago, I've always been on the firm left, and in recent years, I've never fallen for the proposition by some on the left that either Putin or Russia are bastions of Socialism. No matter how you try to spin it, in a breach of international law, without any valid justification, PUTIN INVADED UKRAINE and not the other way around! As such, UKRAINE HAS THE RIGHT OF SELF DEFENCE. If Ukraine wishes to try and enlist the help of other countries in its fight to stop Putin, good luck to it even though it may be availing itself of the maxim " my enemy's enemy is my friend". Your proposition that Ukraine is fighting a proxy war on behalf of the USA is totally bonkers. The USA may have a political motive in seeing Putin beaten but they certainly did not pin him against a wall and tell him to invade Ukraine so that they and others could make a fortune out of selling arms to Ukraine! Putin is a thug and a liar and is 100% guilty of invading a sovereign country, a war crime. His excuses that either NATO or Ukraine were a threat are bogus, and simply a sop to anyone who has any sympathy for his brutal behaviour which has cost the lives of thousands and has now backfired on him. With luck, it will lead to his own downfall.
ReplyDeletehttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BDJa6malQes
DeleteThey're just Putin apologists according to Jack T.
thanks but next time someone posts a link to youtube can you give a brief description so that I don't inadvertently publish pro-NATO nonsense?
DeleteOk, will do. Thankfully on this occasion thats not the case because its from the Marx Engels Institute podcast.
Delete@Jack T like the Putin regime, the Zelensky regime is anti.left wing and it's been responsible like Putin at suppression of trade unions, socialists and the Romanies as well as forcing it's male population to become cannon fodder.
DeleteHow anyone can ignore this who claims to be on the left is dire and I guess you are ok with this.
Tonyhag the things you say may well be true, I don't dispute them, but they are a long way from giving Putin any excuse to invade Ukraine, a sovereign nation.
DeleteAre you still a member of Unite and if so why?
ReplyDeleteIsn't it a bit hypocritical of you to be shunning Ukrainian far right nationalists, but being ok with and making excuses for Palestinian nationalists, who also had links with Nazism, or is the latter really in a different league, and if so, give examples rather than just deflecting ?
ReplyDeleteour resident Zio is at it again.
DeleteNo prominent Palestinian nationalists had links with Nazism. Only the British and Zionist appointed Mufti who was elected by no Palestinian.
But the Lehi/Stern Zionist terror group OFFERED A MILITARY PACT to the Nazis - twice and its leader was future Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir.
Not forgetting the Nazi-Zionist trade agreement Ha'avarah of course and the German Zionist Federation pressurising the Ge stapo not to allow Jews to go to any country bar Palestine.
So Mr Zio next time how about focussing on the Jewish neo-Nazis in power today like Smotrich and Gvir instead of mythical Palestinians, eh?
To yet another 'Anonymous': What a joke, you are labelling Palestinians who are campaigning to be allowed to return to homes and land where they have lived for millenia, which were stolen from them by Zionists mainly from Europe who had absolutely no connection with Palestine, as nationalists! Remember what that horrible woman Golda Meir, another Zionist, said about Palestinian children - she dreams of the day she can wake up and they will all be dead!
DeleteI quite agree that Jack T's post in unadulterated propaganda and again it is by somebody who has not read the history of 2014 and the deliberate murder of 40 plus trade unionists in Odessa when the Trade Union Meeting hall was firebombed by Right wing Nationalist Thugs neither have they read the history and the USA involvement in getting rid of the elected President and supporting regime change which has led to chaos in every country that the USA UK and EU have gone to war against such as Libya, Iraq, Syria Lebanon and so on.Why is everybody afraid to say that the aim of the Neo fascists in Ukraine is to remove the ethnic Russians who mainly live in the Donbas region which has been at war with the Ukrainian nationalists ,Fascists since 2014. I dont support Putin but I do understand that he feels threatened by NATO having standing armies surrounding his European borders and the possibility that they would cut his access to the Black Sea.
ReplyDeleteAnonymous: Apart from the fact that I am fully aware of the history of Ukraine, including the adulation some Ukrainians have for Bandera the killer nationalist, whom you didn't mention, you are painting Putin as some sort of simpleton who was easily provoked. Putin is anything but, he did not require any sort of provocation to invade Ukraine, it has been in his sights for years. Putin is a cold hearted psychopath who does not care how many lives he sacrifices in persuit of his obsession. To such an extent that he has even bombed those people in the Donbas he lied about wanting to protect. By saying that you understand he feels threatened, you are playing right into his hands by echoing the excuses he has given, please don't be a useful fool. It was Ukraine and Ukrainians he invaded and murdered, how on earth were they any threat to him, even IF they had joined NATO?
Delete