The term ‘cleanse’ has a particular resonance in terms of the Holocaust. After the start of Operation Barbarossa in June 1941 an area was ‘cleansed’ when there were no Jews left alive. For example according to a situation report by Himmler in February 1942: ‘While the Jewish question in the Ostland can be seen as practically solved and cleansed, progress continues to be made on the clarification of this problem on other occupied territories in the east."[Irving v Penguin Books Ltd and another, para. 6.20 of the Judgment of Gray J, 11.4.00]
In a Report for Channel 4 News, Alex Thompson described how soldiers involved in the invasion of Gaza were ordered to ‘cleanse’ Palestinian neighbourhoods.
It is no surprise that, yet again, Nazi terminology of destruction and death is now employed by Israel against the Palestinians. Although Israel is not, yet, a fascist state embarked on extermination of the enemy, the mental attitude vs the Palestinians is extremely similar. Just as Jews were considered vermin to be ‘cleansed’ in by the Nazi state, so Palestinians are also regarded as sub-human, beasts on 2 legs as Menachem Begin once said.
Following on from the call for death camps in a orthodox religious magazine, we now learn that soldiers were ordered to embark on ‘cleansing’ operations, having been promised a ‘shoah’ [holocaust] by Deputy Defence Minister Matan Vilnai.
Tony Greenstein
Israeli Soldiers Ordered to ‘Cleanse’ Gaza During Invasion in 2008/9
Israel's invasion of Gaza deliberately aimed to "cleanse" Palestinian neighbourhoods, former soldiers allege, in claims that will reignite the debate over the campaign's legality, writes Alex Thomson.
Israel's controversial invasion of Gaza deliberately aimed to "cleanse" Palestinian neighbourhoods, former soldiers have alleged, in claims that will reignite the debate over the legality of the three week military campaign two years ago.
Israel invaded Gaza at the end of 2008 in a bid to halt rocket attacks from the territory it ceded in 2005. It says it focused on military targets controlled by Hamas, the Palestinian militant group, and bitterly countered a 2009 UN report that stated civilians had been deliberately targeted.
But in startling interviews with Israeli filmmaker Nurit Kedar for her film Concrete, former soldiers have for the first time allowed themselves to be named while blaming their commanders for encouraging a "disproportionate" response to Hamas's rockets. They said their commanders used to "psych up" soldiers before an operation so they were ready to shoot indiscriminately.
One soldier says he was told to shell every house in a neighbourhood. Richard Goldstone’s report for the UN alleged that war crimes and possible crimes against humanity committed by both sides, but highlighted the moral and legal severity of the IDF's attacks.
The IDF [Israel Defence Forces] has said its operational orders during the war emphasised "proportionality" and "humanity". The importance of minimizing harm to civilians was made clear to soldiers, the IDF said at the time. By the end of the 22 day long operation some 1,400 Palestinians had been killed and large areas of Gaza razed. Ten Israeli soldiers and three Israeli civilians also died.
Soldier stories
In a report to be shown on Channel 4 News this week, 24-year-old tank commander Ohad remembers being told the night before the operation that the entry into Gaza was to be "disproportionate". Once into Gaza, he says his orders were unambiguous:
"The order was very clear that if a car came within 200 metres of me I could simply shoot at it. Shoot a shell at it."
Some of the most disputed claims about the operation centre around firing at family homes and mosques.
Ohad also says: "We needed to cleanse the neighbourhoods, the buildings, the area. It sounds really terrible to say "cleanse", but those were the orders....I don't want to make a mistake with the words."
Thirty-year-old Shay who was in the Elite Combat Unit, still appears disturbed by taking over the house of a wealthy Palestinian family to fight Operation Cast Lead. He recalls being disgusted that Israeli conscripts had already defecated all over the bathroom of this family house. The family photos had been scrawled over. Graffiti was on the walls saying "long live Israel".
"All the time we were there you could sense this family with us. Meaning they were there. All the clichés. There was a wooden rocking horse, I remember, you’d be on guard and next to you there's a wooden rocking-horse," Shay says.
Last year, the UN criticised Israel and Hamas for failing to adequately investigate the findings of its report.
Today, the Israeli Embassy said: "Over 12,000 rockets and shells rained down on Israeli civilians from Gaza forcing the IDF to carry out a military operation. "Unlike much of the region, the open society within Israel allows for all allegations such as these to be aired and investigated. Israel has already authorised over 100 separate investigations into the operation, five broader investigations, and close to 50 criminal investigations are also taking place. Our judicial process is renowned across the world for its independence."
It remains of course beyond belief that there are still Serious People [cough!] who have no qualms at promoting the idea of wholesale population transfers. From my reading the Nazis' initial intention towards European Jewry was also to resettle, rather than exterminate. Barely fifty years after those facts, Zionist mouthpieces have little problem imagining similar solutions to fulfil the dream of an ethnically pure Jewish state. Naziesque ideas clearly aren’t inherent to the Nazis only…
ReplyDeleteUs humans just don't seem to be making much progress, on the whole. Although we do have much netter gadgets for mass murder at our fingertips, so I suppose that's something...
Gert
ReplyDeleteyes the original Nazi plan was also transfer, to Madagascar and then Lublin where they planned a Jewish reservation. But I would argue that extermination was always implicit in Nazism as per Hitler's speech of January 30 1933 where he spoke of the annihilation of the Jewish people.
Hopefully, Israel's judiciary process will really investigate the truth about the invasion of Gaza. And after the investigation, it will be transparent about the findings and that the people who have committed the crime will be made to pay.
ReplyDeleteI'm afraid the Israeli judiciary is part of the cover up. The Turkel Commission has just reported and it is a complete whitewash. They didn't even interview anyone who was on board and took as accepted the testimony of Gabi Ashkenazi of Shin Bet and others involved.
ReplyDeleteNo attempts were made to interview those on board.
And of course Israel put every obstacle in the way of the Goldstone Commission, preventing access to Gaza from Israel, preventing him meeting people in Sderot and then launching an attack on the Report. The criticism was not of the details but because it disagreed with the Israeli version of events.
But since Turkel himself made his views known before chairing the report this is all no surprise. The 2 'independent' members included David Trimble, leader of the Ulster Unionists in Northern Ireland, an Orange bigot and the ex-President of Peru, a war criminal in his own right.
The Israeli judiciary today is unlikely to upset the apple cart