Israeli Police Simply Ignore Court Order to Release Palestinian –

Jewish Co-defendants Tried Under Different Legal System

The police took Nasser Nawaj’ah out of the West Bank and into Israel to face trial. When that didn’t work, they ignored a court order to release him and smuggled him back to the West Bank and into military custody.

Despite calling itself the ‘only democracy in the Middle East’ Israel behaves very much like a police state when it comes to Palestinians.  In the saga below, a Palestinian, Nasser Nawaj’ah, is charged with making a complaint to Palestinian police about another Palestinian.  Apparently that is an offence under Military Regulations which are not published, still less translated, into Arabic.

The two Jewish co-defendants, who are alleged to have also informed the Palestinian police about someone who fraudulently sold land to settlers, who would therefore be subject to imprisonment, are being tried under Israeli law.  In fact there was no land seller.  It was all a set-up by a right-wing Zionist NGO to entrap Jewish human rights workers who opposed the sale of Palestinian land to Zionist settlers.

Khirbet Susiya

When the Israeli police produced Nasser Nawaj’ah in question before the Jerusalem Magistrates Court it was ordered that he be released as the Court had no jurisdiction in the case, because he was a Palestinian.  The Police promptly appealed and the Jerusalem District Court also ruled that Nasser Nawaj’ah should be set free.  What did the Police do?  Instead of releasing him they kidnapped him and took him to the West  Bank where they charged him before a Military Court, where the rights of defendants are non-existent.  The courts have a conviction rate of 99.7%.

One of the essential prerequisites of a bourgeois democracy is the rule of law.  In Israel the Police choose which legal system with which to charge someone.  If they can’t do it under one system they choose another!

Tony Greenstein

By Haggai Matar

|Published January 22, 2016

Israeli police smuggle Palestinian suspect out of the country

Palestinian anti-occupation activist Nasser Nawajah is led into the Jerusalem Magistrate’s Court, January 21, 2016. (photo: Oren Ziv/Activestills.org)

What happened to a Palestinian man named Nasser Nawaj’ah on Thursday could fill an entire chapter of a textbook about the Israeli justice system, or rather, about its military occupation.

Related stories

By Dahlia Scheindlin | January 15, 2016

Nasser was arrested in the West Bank by Israeli soldiers on suspicion of filing a complaint to the Palestinian police about another Palestinian. The soldiers hand him over to Israeli police, who take him from the West Bank to Israel. There, a Jerusalem Magistrate’s Court judge rules that the court doesn’t have jurisdiction over Palestinians, and orders him released unconditionally. The police appeal the judge’s decision, but the Jerusalem District Court also rules that it doesn’t have jurisdiction, and once again orders the police to release the man unconditionally.

The Israeli police ignore the Israeli court’s decision, take the Palestinian man outside Israel’s sovereign borders and bring him to the Ofer Military Court in the occupied West Bank. There, Israeli authorities ask a military judge (who is actually a major in the army) to extend the Palestinian man’s remand. The man’s lawyer is not present this time. She is still back in Israel, in Jerusalem, busy filing an emergency petition to hold the police in contempt of court.

Nasser Nawaj’ah explains to the military court that all he did was to report to the Palestinian police a Palestinian man who he thought was trying to harm him, and that he doesn’t understand why that could possibly be illegal.

The military court judge says he feels “uncomfortable” with how this is all happening, and with the fact that Israeli authorities transferred a Palestinian man from a court “in Israel” to a court in “the region” (the West Bank). In other words: this is the opposite of the normal scenario, in which Palestinians are brought only to military courts in “the region.” Nevertheless, the military judge rules that Nawaj’ah be kept in custody until Sunday, using the charming logic that in military courts — as opposed to civilian courts — four days in jail isn’t anything to get worked up about.

WATCH: Anti-occupation activists brought to J’lem court

Meanwhile, the petition to hold the police in contempt of court is still pending. Recall that the police completely disregarded and mocked the District Court’s order to unconditionally release Nasser Nawaj’ah, instead smuggling him out of the country and out of the court’s jurisdiction.

All of this happened while two other arrestees in the same case, suspected of the same crimes, and who happen to be Jewish, are processed though an entirely different legal system.

Amazing, isn’t it?

Update: On Friday morning, Nawaj’ah’s attorney filed an emergency petition for writ of habeus corpus to the Israeli High Court of Justice.